Wait, wait. We're complaining that Kirk became captain of the Enterprise at the end of the movie?
Why the fuck was Luke handed a space F16 at the end of Star Wars, with zero experience in a dogfight? It's not like he'd done ANYTHING of worth in that movie aside from clutch his sister real hard while swinging across a 20 foot chasm and manning a turret, if I recall. Wheras JTK fucking beat a time travelling badass Romulan with a ship that singlehandedly destroyed like 8 Constitution class starships- through sheer will and strategy. Kirk proved himself as a tactical commander, as a leader, and as a man committed to Starfleet.
It's a fucking movie. Starfleet is not real- I hate to break your heart, Brandon from Galaxy Quest- but it is NOT key that they follow strict military procedure. Let's be honest, 60's Kirk would be fired from any real life military organization so fast your head would spin.
He's a badass cowboy with a good heart and a good head that WILL NOT GIVE UP even when it doesn't look like he's got a chance in hell. Go get some more guys and then it'll be a fair fight.
How could you possibly have a problem with that?