Finally saw it, and you guys are being way too kind. It's forgettable and mediocre at best.
That't it, it's over folks. No one knows how to make sci-fi action movies anymore. If the guy who made District 9 can botch it like this, with basically full creative control, an R-rating, and 100 million dollar budget, it ain't happening.
What's funny is that it fails in exactly the opposite way that I thought it would. Going in, I figured it'd be overly preachy and push the 99% thing agenda, when in fact it ends up underplaying and mostly abandoning that stuff in favor of being an action movie. Which I would've been totally fine with, a hard-R relentless action movie from the guy who did the crazy awesome District-9 finale...bring it on. What I didn't expect though, is how much it FAILS at being an action movie. I count 2 action set-pieces in this whole thing (you could count the shuttle crash bit as #3, but it lasts about 30 seconds), totalling maybe 15 minutes, almost all of it shot close-up and completely incomprehensible. The big finale fight is so underwhelming, hard to follow, and BORING, it absolutely kills me. Compare that with what James Cameron did in the finale of The Terminator, for like 5 million dollars, and it's not even close.
That's the weird thing with this movie, much like District 9, it wants to be a combination social-commentary back-drop, and intense violent action film, but unlike District 9, it fails at both the commentary (by abandoning it and having a main story that really doesn't make any goddamn sense) and the action (which is way too infrequent and forgettable). I'd say it starts out great for about 40 minutes, up through the 1st heist sequence, which I actually think is really good. Then, when it should be ramping up and upping the ante, it goes into a super routine and boring climax. I think there'd be a lot less complaints about the holes in the story if the movie really knocked you on your ass at the end. They've setup Copley as this demented crazy antagonist, how about
SPOILER
ShowDamon's suit gets stripped away, and him and the girl have to try to escape and defeat this crazed mech-suit powered bad guy as Damon is getting progressively weaker and weaker.
This gets me thinking on what the hell has happened to memorable set-pieces in movies. Look at a movie like the original Total Recall. That's got a great sci-fi premise, full of twists and turns and sly commentary. But I can also list off at least 6 memorable action sequences, each with some unique setting, or weapon, or adversary. And it all fits into 2 hours, while doing plenty of world-building, and establishing way more characters than Elysium does.
Frankly, I don't know where all the runtime is going, but it feels like the movie is just spinning it's wheels for large chunks.
SPOILER
ShowThey could start by losing the AWFUL AWFUL "you're destined for greatness" flashback sequences and the terrible scenes with Alice Braga's daughter.
I will say though, visually, it is fucking outstanding. Flawless vfx work throughout.