Just saw MoS today. My opinion of pretty much everyone involved in the creative process has been lowered substantionally.
In almost every scene there were things I objected to. Either how certain things were handled, how the scene lacks any emotional context to engage me in the moment we are watching, or how obvious things that could have been done weren't done.
This film is a particle effects demo. This is derivative almost to Oblivion levels. I had lowered my expectations going in to it, and yet I could not help from zoning out so many times. This is literally the plot of Transformers 3 (bring the alien world to earth through magic bean/alien device) with the fights from Iron Man 2 and The Matrix rehashed at the end.
The destruction of Metropolis was operating at parody levels. I've seen a few mentions of the movie being bold or noteworthy for actually going to new levels of 9/11 references. In fact this is the most mindless, anonymous, unengaging, video-game destruction I've yet seen, and I fail to see how anyone could relate in any way to it. Cloverfield tearing down buildings was shocking and realistic (monster aside). This movie is the equivalent of playing with a Ragdoll simulation game and trying to relate emotionally with the faceless, grey plastic doll you are continously throwing down stairs in various inventive ways. I don't see how it's even possible.
Hans Zimmer is remixing himself as intensly as ever. I heard a complete re-orchestration of an Angels & Demons theme in here, note for note with the same violin playing. I don't care if they temp-scored it and wanted the same thing, have SOME intellectual integrity.
MoS- Krypton's Last: http://youtu.be/vQh085jWYpQ?t=40s
A&D - God Save Us: http://youtu.be/edH8bFmIgvI?t=3m33s
I NEED someone to Plinkett or FIYH this movie once it hits retail. How did everyone , sans CGI artists and actors doing their best, botch this so badly?
One scene had me emotionally engaged to the point of slight shivers (cold theater though...) and that was the flying scene right after he dons the cape and suit. And anyone could make a CGI scene of a guy shooting through the air with jet sounds and sonic booms, aided by Hans Zimmer having an entire orchestra plus a godless amount of synthesizers playing powerchords, be powerful.
Not only would I not recommend MoS, I would rather watch Transformers 3 over this. This movie actually made me feel this way, and I kind of hate it for it.