Dorkman wrote:Are you really saying you think it's entirely likely there were NO capable actors who matched the character's described appearance more closely?
Almost. I am suggesting that out of everyone who auditioned for the role, he was the best fit for it, for any number of reasons, of which skin tone is only one. And that the showrunners, having to make many tradeoffs per day to make the best product possible, ultimately decided that he possessed some quality or essence of the character that was more important than his skin tone being slightly off. At the end of the day, producers and casting directors are constrained by the set of actors that walk through their door.
And this is accepting the premise that his skin tone is in fact too light, which I don't. The Dornish are proxies for Spanish and Mediterranean ethnicities and I think Chilean is related closely enough that it's not the best time to call in the Outrage Squad. And maybe not judging his skin tone from a photo where he's standing six inches from the flash might also be in order, hence the waiting to see him in costume and on set.
Allison wrote:I am fairly sure that there are non-white talented people out there. But were they allowed to audition? Were they seriously considered?
I'm not saying this isn't a problem, I'm just saying that this maybe isn't the hill to die on.
Allison wrote:Or maybe the casting call called only for white actors, like 70% of them do.
And also, not to get too sharp, but this is an accusation for which you have no evidence other than a statistic, which is weak evidence for any individual situation, especially for a show already as multiethnic as Game of Thrones.