^

As for commentary recommendations/avoidances.

Ultraviolet - Milla on her own didn't work for me, felt she needed someone else there (Director and/or Producer like others do) to bounce off of.
whereas John Rambo - just Sly but it never felt like he was scampering (probably the wrong word) around for something to say - though I'm still not sure if I'm allowed to enjoy this as a kick-ass, explosion filled, limbs flying, body shredding, blood splattered blast of a movie when (as he says in his commentary) it is also a horrific depiction of the real-life horrors being carried out in Burma right now.
Cast commentaries absent of the main actor (Doomsday - no Rhona Mitra) feel incomplete.
and the first Pirates movie (the commentary by the writers) I found most interesting - how the story was cobbled together by taking different acts from different peoples drafts.
and finally , loved the one for Jason X - a bunch of people who loved the series and grew tired of waiting for JvF to get upnrunning, so went out and made themselves a movie (ish) - whereas the JvF one (imho) would have greatly benefiited from Sean Cunninghams involvement - we got Robert Englund to give the Freddy perspective, bring all his history from the previous films, but there was noone to speak with authority about Jason since this was Ken Kirzinger's first time. Sean could have done that. 

a Blu Ray player is on my to-buy list, right under a bigass tv. (3rd on the list is Serenity for the cast commentary  , the DVD only having Joss's one  )

^ I don't want you to leave either  , but would you like a Scottish Passport, cos I sure would like an English one (not that darn British one  )

iirc all it took was for a small bunch of "England is for whities, everyone else should just go home" people to drape themselves in the flag. Then England, as a country, seemed to willingly accept the flag no longer represented "yay England" but "yay White England". Which is a darn shame as my working thesis is that many of the current woes of society (highest teen pregnancy being one) could be solved/helped if the country was given a boost to its selfworth/self pride, and this could be achieved with the mass flyings of the flag EVERYWHERE.
As for the being like America - current (iiuc) anyone born here to nonUK nationals is considered British (even if they are born in England and go on to live their whole lives in England). I'd love to see England adopt the Americanism of "if you're born in England then you're English. This would quickly remove the easily laid charge that George Cross wavers are celebrating their Whiteness because we'd have a multitude of skin colours waving and proclaiming their "yay England" ness - which'd be awesome. .

You go but I go

The ending ruined, well maybe not ruined the movie but definately left me feeling huh? -

<- info in picture form

is that the 1980 special edition or 1998 collector's edition ?

[edit] collector's edition it is 

Constantine - the best example of "what is a perfect movie" commentary

^didn't you do Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon ?
(goes off to check)
[edit] Yup

Quick question: does Bender have the same 'other' meaning in America as it does in England, because I couldn't watch the movie without smirking at every mention of an AirBender and WoodBender etc etc (and yes I am THAT juvenial,  or I would be if I could spell it)

Quick question: did you know what Phi's final numbers were BEFORE you guys picked your movies and added in your votes ? Should I be wondering if there was some anti-bunnyness conspiracy afoot to keep out Roger Rabbit ???????

Note to self: next time I'll do my own count ~15mins before the end, then tweak my votes  if one of mine is just out of the top 6.

btw: I've just checked and none of the winners has a directors cut or extended version.