926

(24 replies, posted in Off Topic)

Hell to the no.

Harry isn't like James Bond or Indiana Jones. He wasn't created to have thrilling but essentially unrelated adventures for as long as the author can come up with something. The Potter novels are one story about Harry's lifelong (at least until the age of 17) epic struggle with the incarnation of Ultimate Evil. It's not wizard of the week episodic stuff. You could do more stories with him like that, but the real story's been told, and anything else would feel feeble and desperate.

It's like we say on the show, a movie should ideally be about the most interesting thing that ever happened to those characters. I loved LOTR, but I'm not interested in a new movie about Sam's tenure as mayor of Hobbiton in the years that followed. There is no amount of thwarted turnip thieving that makes that as worth telling as the time he helped save the world from Sauron.

EDIT: it's also why I've never wanted to see a fourth BACK TO THE FUTURE. In the end, the trilogy is a single story (which, if we're honest, goes to the frontier-town mansion in the third act). The story was all wrapped up in the end. Another film would feel like the odd man out.

927

(56 replies, posted in Episodes)

I have no idea what you just said.

928

(56 replies, posted in Episodes)

929

(1,019 replies, posted in Episodes)

930

(47 replies, posted in Episodes)

The two parallel lines on the left side wall being indicated as at a right angle to each other breaks my brain.

931

(21 replies, posted in Episodes)

I don't know why this is making the rounds today as a big bombshell. Spielberg has openly hated the aliens aspect in every interview since before they even shot the thing. It's why it took almost 20 years to make the film -- Lucas said it was aliens or nothing, so Spielberg said it would be nothing. Until, for some reason, he gave in.

The actual, stunning news here is that Spielberg is responsible for the fridge.

933

(4 replies, posted in Off Topic)

Meh. It's not like studios and rental houses are buying new cams all the time, the existing cameras -- assuming repairs and maintenance will be continued -- will continue to be viable for decades. There are probably cams from the 70s and 80s still going out on sets and getting the job done.

When Kodak and Fuji stop making celluloid, THAT'S the fat lady hitting high-C. And that'll come, but it'll be a while yet.

You've posted this in the wrong thread; therefore Kubrick is a genius.

935

(30 replies, posted in Episodes)

Go for it, switch. I wasn't planning to write it.

936

(2,061 replies, posted in Episodes)

937

(30 replies, posted in Episodes)

938

(27 replies, posted in Off Topic)

939

(27 replies, posted in Off Topic)

Yeah, I was trying to find a nicer way of saying "If you think the characters are undeveloped, you probably weren't paying attention."

940

(44 replies, posted in Episodes)

Confused Matthew thinks CRYSTAL SKULL is a good movie. His argument is invalid.

941

(27 replies, posted in Off Topic)

DRIVE is awesome. What it isn't is a movie that's going to explain itself for the cheap seats. It's being sold as an action movie, but it's the kind of movie that would be considered actiony in the 60s, not today. It's more of a thriller and a drama, and the characters are plenty developed, but the movie doesn't tell you about them by having them speak. If you're not willing to do some legwork and engage with the movie rather than sit back and have the movie explain itself to you, then DRIVE is the wrong movie for you.

942

(47 replies, posted in Episodes)

I'm more inclined to think that he did that because if they were in a real location, the hotel lights would be tungsten and the light coming in from the windows would be daylight, so he had the lights in the hotel area be tungsten and the lights coming in from the windows be daylight so that it felt like moving through a real location and not a set.

I'll go so far as to grant that this could very well have been a deliberate choice to make the movie more creepy in the sense that making the hotel feel like a real place in the real world makes the horror more relatable and more effective. But I'm not willing to go so far as to think there's some "using the subliminal discomfort of non-complementary color palattes" senior thesis type justification behind it. That tastes like Kool-Aid to me.

943

(47 replies, posted in Episodes)

944

(10 replies, posted in Creations)

Just about every podcast I listen to these days has a Skype component. The FXGuide/phd/RedCentre guys are all over the world and interview people spread about likewise, The Skeptics Gude to the Universe is all done over Skype... There was a time when Skype was ganky and unreliable, but that was years ago.

That being said, we can barely manage to keep any given episode from imploding technologically with everyone present in one room, so I can understand the reticence toward trying to add a remote contributor to DIF. But maybe we could experiment for the Intermission.

945

(1,019 replies, posted in Episodes)

946

(2,061 replies, posted in Episodes)

KUNG FU HUSTLE is one of my absolute favorite films. (I know I say that about a lot of movies. I have a lot of favorites. But I loathe a lot of movies, too, so the net energy of the universe remains zero.) But I don't expect we'll do a DIF of it. I think it might be a wee bit esoteric.

Don't let the door hit you, princess.

Anyway, actually on the topic, an addendum I wanted to make in the following ep but didn't get around to is that when I say it's a big no-no to give your script to someone if you know it has problems, I mean to say that if you're giving it to someone and you know it has problems that you could fix, and have just chosen not to before giving it to them, that's lazy and shitty and you ought to be caned in the street.

On the other hand, if you know the script has problems and you can't figure out how to fix them, and the point of giving it to that person is to get a new perspective and maybe some new ideas for solutions, then of course that's perfectly valid and a great reason to seek a second pair of eyes.