Topic: Attack the Block

Teague Chrystie

I have a tendency to fix your typos.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

I'll share my thoughts on this film later but right now, I have a technical question about this episode. I just downloaded the file, so is the bit rate supposed to be in 64k? The episode sounds tinny. Contagion was in 160k.

Last edited by johnpavlich (2013-09-02 05:52:37)

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

Yeah, I'm seeing if anyone minds me reigning in the file size. This one is 46 megs, Contagion was 140.

Teague Chrystie

I have a tendency to fix your typos.

Thumbs up +2 Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

My podcast episodes are 64k mono only because they have to be. I have a limited amount of storage space each month (250 megs), so compression must take place. I've yet to run into many people here who think the file sizes should be smaller. I mean, I'm happy with the download taking longer if it means the audio sounds better/cleaner. It's kind of odd to use that professional setup you have with all that nice equipment, only to then output to 64k. Just my opinion, maybe I'm alone here and should shut up and enjoy the free thing. smile

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

Interesting... haven't listened yet, but I hated this film, mostly on principle.

Imagination will often carry us to worlds that never were. But without it we go nowhere. - Carl Sagan

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

C'mon guys, Moose aren't THAT scary. I had some in my backyard the other night... but unless you hit them with your car, and unless you walked in on their kids... they run from you. Very shy.

Well.

Generally.

smile

/Z

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

Yeah, Moose are like the least scary thing we have around here, massive as all hell, but generally very docile.

Oh and yeah, if you hit them going highway speeds there is no hope, your car and you are paste.

http://www.alaskanhome.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2009/11/Midtown-Moose.jpg

ZangrethorDigital.ca

Re: Attack the Block

Honestly.... I much rather not find something deadly in my toilet myself.

/Z

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

Oh and wait what?

WHAT?

Teague must have me mixed up with someone else.... LOL.

We don't have that much guns in Sweden... And they aren't reall "handed out"....well....apart from when we do our military service (which isn't even mandatory any more).... but oh they absolutely take them back when they send you home. smile

Owning a gun is a ton of red tape and headache. You need a licence to own a weapon, and getting it is tricky, unless you can motivate the gun for hunting or sports (you can never motivate it for defense, since it's not legal to use for defense).

As far as I know... using a gun against a human is strictly forbidden unless you are a police officer, under pretty much any circumstance .... There is some leeway for "self defense", but basically you must absolutely be in absolutely doubtlessly deadly peril with absolutely no other option whatsoever...

Must sound very Alien to an American, but.... yeah.

EDIT: Having said all the above, I should add that my brother has a bunch of guns and actually volounteers as keeper of a shooting range, and it actually turns out that Sweden - to my own surprise - ranks surprisingly high in "gun ownership" according to the interwebs. Interesting... most likely due to our hunting tradition and I'd guess 90% of these are hunting rifles.... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_co … _ownership smile  (Frankly I think the statistic seeming high comes more from the fact that there are only 9 million of us, rather than there being a lot of guns...)

/Z

Last edited by MasterZap (2013-09-02 10:34:09)

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

Maybe Swede guys with guns manage to reproduce more smile

I write stories! With words!
http://www.asstr.org/~Invid_Fan/

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

Haven't heard the episode yet, but everyone in Switzerland gets a rifle.

http://blog.gunspec.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/swiss2.jpg

Thumbs up +1 Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

MasterZap wrote:

C'mon guys, Moose aren't THAT scary. I had some in my backyard the other night... but unless you hit them with your car, and unless you walked in on their kids... they run from you. Very shy.

Well.

Generally.

smile

/Z

Um, methinks you need to meet a North Idaho moose then, since a friend of mine was chased down by one on his snowmobile and kept in a creek bed for over an hour by another one.

God loves you!

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

I basically have the same issues with this movie that I have with Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World. It's fun, creative, well directed and entertaining but that's all surface stuff and I find it lacking beyond the technical accomplishments. And just like Pilgrim, it tries to have some sort of substantial arc or message towards the end but by then, it's too little, too late and doesn't feel earned at all. It seems to justify the kids' actions as being that of a poor man stealing bread to feed his starving family and I don't agree with that. These kids (most of them, anyway) come off more as delinquent sociopaths who steal and threaten because they enjoy terrorizing people, rather than poor castoffs, forced into a life of crime in order to survive. I call bullshit.

Then you have the two little kids, Probz and Mayhem. They idolize these older thug kids and want to be one of them. The movie seems to be fine with this idea and actually sets that as a reward for them, so we're supposed to be happy for them when they get what they want, having suffered no consequences for attaining that goal. To me, that's horrible!

The ending of the movie reaffirms this message, when Moses, the leader of this gang who assaulted a Woman at the start and threatened her with a knife, destroys the monsters and "saves the day" and everyone, EVERYONE is cheering him on as a Hero, which makes no sense because most of those people in that crowd don't even know who the hell he is!

While I understand the movie is about "community" and all that, I don't think the movie does a good enough job to make it clear that the "block" is some kind of close-knit "family" who are all in this together and take care of their own.

Don't get me wrong, I like the movie, I just don't think it's a particularly good movie, which is exactly how I feel about Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World.

Thumbs up +2 Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

Oops. Sorry, Zap. I must have been thinking of Switzerland.

holden

Teague Chrystie

I have a tendency to fix your typos.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

fireproof78 wrote:

Um, methinks you need to meet a North Idaho moose then, since a friend of mine was chased down by one on his snowmobile and kept in a creek bed for over an hour by another one.

Wasn't that the plot of Moose II: The Moosening ?

Never encountered a moose in the wild myself, but I understand they can turn aggressive and unpredictable during mating season.

Moose.  So like us.

Re: Attack the Block

http://i.imm.io/1gWSp.jpeg

Teague Chrystie

I have a tendency to fix your typos.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

Yup, I have the same problems with this as Pavlich. We're forced to 'protagonise' these vile, loathsome shits, and not nearly enough of them are mauled horribly by the creatures.

Imagination will often carry us to worlds that never were. But without it we go nowhere. - Carl Sagan

Thumbs up +1 Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

redxavier wrote:

Yup, I have the same problems with this as Pavlich. We're forced to 'protagonise' these vile, loathsome shits, and not nearly enough of them are mauled horribly by the creatures.

To paraphrase Teague: "This guy.... This guy." smile

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

johnpavlich wrote:

These kids (most of them, anyway) come off more as delinquent sociopaths who steal and threaten because they enjoy terrorizing people, rather than poor castoffs, forced into a life of crime in order to survive. I call bullshit.

They do it because that is what they know, basically. The film should have shown more of that, though.

Then you have the two little kids, Probz and Mayhem. They idolize these older thug kids and want to be one of them. The movie seems to be fine with this idea and actually sets that as a reward for them, so we're supposed to be happy for them when they get what they want, having suffered no consequences for attaining that goal. To me, that's horrible!

Yeah, there should have been some scene of the younger kids deciding not to grow up to be like that.


While I understand the movie is about "community" and all that, I don't think the movie does a good enough job to make it clear that the "block" is some kind of close-knit "family" who are all in this together and take care of their own.

No, it's really just the kids that are a family. The drug dealers feign the whole family thing to get what they want from the kids (especially from Moses). The whole block aren't close-knit as is shown with the older woman helping Sam and her disdain for the little thugs.

redxavier wrote:

Yup, I have the same problems with this as Pavlich. We're forced to 'protagonise' these vile, loathsome shits, and not nearly enough of them are mauled horribly by the creatures.

That's the thing, though, two of them die, it's not as though this lot gets through this thing without a scratch. Plus, they got arrested too, they blew part of a building and Ron will get done for having all that dope. Just because they don't focus on consequences doesn't mean there aren't any. I don't say I disagree with you or Pavlich to a degree but I definitely like the film more.

Thumbs up +1 Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

Yeah, the "every movie must save the world" mentality also applies to characters.  It's important to have a character or characters change over the course of the movie, but it doesn't have to be a galactic change.   An ending where Moses announces his decision to go to law school, or in which he and British Felicia Day get married, would have been more than a little ridiculous.

Instead, the change is just that the main characters - who started out seeing each other as faceless thugs vs unimportant victim - now see each other as people.   Moses is probably gonna do some time, but overall this experience may have set him on a different path in life.   That's not a big change, but it's a change, and that can be enough.

Re: Attack the Block

And despite being hailed as a hero for killing the aliens, Moses still knows he was responsible in the first place for killing the female alien. He knows his two friends died because of him, how can he face their parents now?

Oh, and who will get blamed for killing the two cops? Just because the films ends with people cheering does not make everything ok.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

Trey wrote:

An ending where Moses announces his decision to go to law school, or in which he and British Felicia Day get married, would have been more than a little ridiculous.

Yes, that would. Thankfully, no one here is asking for that.

Trey wrote:

Moses is probably gonna do some time, but overall this experience may have set him on a different path in life.

That may be true, but it's meaningless since the rest of those kids don't appear to have learned a damn thing, not to mention you now have the Junior Thugs to take Moses's place. Two of them. The thugs and their victim(s) see each other as people. How swell for them. I'm not buying it as enough for me to overlook what they've done and will most likely continue to do.

Maybe if they were merely pick pockets? A crime like that doesn't do any physical or psychological damage, as far as I know.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

Jimmy B wrote:

And despite being hailed as a hero for killing the aliens, Moses still knows he was responsible in the first place for killing the female alien. He knows his two friends died because of him, how can he face their parents now?

He never has to. The movie lets him off the hook.

Jimmy B wrote:

Oh, and who will get blamed for killing the two cops? Just because the films ends with people cheering does not make everything ok.

You and I know that. I'm not so sure the movie knows that. For a movie that reports to be all about "Actions have consequences", it feels more like, "Only some actions have consequences. Mostly, all will be forgiven if you apologize in the end, or it's not your fault because you, too are a victim."

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

Fair enough.  Me, I don't need to see redemption at the end of every movie. 

Oddly enough, Attack The Block reminds me of 48 Hours - at the end the criminal is still a criminal, the racist cop is still racist, but they learned to like each other just a little bit, and defeated a bigger threat together.  That's it, but that was enough for me.

I think the "Hollywood ending" of Attack The Block would probably have had Moses die in the blast.  Noble and clean and easier on the taxpayers afterward.

Re: Attack the Block

Heh, yeah.

I don't need to see redemption at the end of every movie, either. I was just asking for a little of it in THIS movie.

From Dusk Till Dawn ends the same way 48 Hours does and I love that movie. "Go home, Kate. I may be a bastard, but I'm not a fucking bastard."

Thumbs up Thumbs down