1.) Citizen Kane (a much-needed injection of golden age cinema to DIF)
2.) Who Framed Roger Rabbit? (so much good to talk about)
3.) Kick-Ass (would love to hear - presumably varied opinions)
4.) Batman Returns (only if you talk about Michelle Pfeiffer for all two hours and nothing else)
5.) The Dark Knight (it has to happen sometime, right?  ...and because Lank has a gun to my head)
6.) Cowboys & Aliens (only to hear everyone shit all over this awful movie)

1.) Battlefield Earth
2.) The Wizard of Oz
3.) Batman Returns
4.) The Dark Knight
5.) Close Encounters of the Third Kind
6.) The Last Airbender

1 Who Framed Roger Rabbit? - how could i not
2 Super 8 - umm i liked it, conversation could be interesting
3 Cowboys & Aliens - this is what not to do
4 The Last Airbender - lends to so much hate and "we can fix it"
5 My Favorite Martian (Trey worked on it)
6 Transformers 3 - the masochist want to complete the set

Glad that you're allowing us to give our opinion on what movies should be done before the shake up that DiF will be going through after March 10th.  Most of the options were difficult to narrow down but for the most part I was able to list them and here it is.

1)  The Dark Knight
2)  Transformers 3 (Mostly since if would be completely the series)
3)  Who Framed Roger Rabbit?
4)  My Favorite Martian (We've gotten some commetiares for movies that Trey has worked on and this would be nice addtion to the list)
5)  Battlefield Earth (A guilty pleasure movie that I like to watch every once and a while)
6)  Super 8

Would like to see Kick-Ass since you guys were actually doing a commentary on it but was left incomplete do to technically difficulties.  Lethal Weapon BARELY missed being added but mostly because of the other things you had.

Hopefully you keep the other movies that won't make the list in consideration to do commentaries in the future.  There are just some there that shouldn't be ignored.

Just curious, but has a start time been determined on when the LotR marathon will be happening on 3/10?

1. Super 8
2. The Dark Knight
3. Transformers 3
4. The Happening
5. The Last Airbender (did Mike not work on it?)
6. Batman Returns

1. Close Enconters
2. Kick Ass
3. The Dark Knight
4.Lethal Weapon
5. The Happening
6. Super 8

alrighty then!

here's my list

1: Unforgiven (You guys need to do one western before you hit LOTR)
2: Close Encounters of the Third Kind (Just want to hear everyone's thoughts on probably Speilberg's best flick)
3: Cowboys vs. Aliens (Trey said that CVA had everything wrong going on in that movie,  You guys tend to do the better comm when you do a movie like this or Surrogates.)
4: The Dark Knight (You must talk about the awful bat-voice)
5: Who Framed Roger Rabbit (I think you guys have only done one Zemekis Flick)
6: Batman Returns (Trey's stories are entertaining)

1. The Dark Knight
2. Batman Returns
3. Super 8
4. Lethal Weapon
5. Who Framed Roger Rabbit?
6. American Beauty

Ooh, so exciting!

1. Lethal Weapon (another classic action movie to add to the collection)
2. Unforgiven (beautiful and brutal film, glad you've got this on your list!)
3. Transformers 3 (shooting fish in a barrel!)
4. The Dark Knight
5. American Beauty (I like Road to Perdition more, but this was a great movie)
6. Batman Returns

I confess I've not even seen most of the rest!

By the way, at this moment, Dark Knight is well ahead (63 points), followed by Transformers 3 and Who Framed the Stupid Rabbit? (33 each), Super 8 (30), and then Close Encounters and Citizen Kane (22)*. Come on guys, are you really going to make me watch Citizen Kane again?
*that is, unless I've forked up!

1. The Dark Knight
2. Kick Ass
3. My Favorite Martian
4. The Wizard of OZ
5. The Last Airbender
6. Who Framed Roger Rabbit