Re: Attack the Block

I think the redemption is there - it's not completely life-altering, but it shows there's more to Moses than just thuggery.  He volunteers to take on the beasts alone, to save everyone else.  But it doesn't make him an instant saint and he still goes to jail, because he should.

I doubt he's gonna take the fall for killing those cops, though - presumably versions of these events played out a dozen times across London that night and there are alien corpses all over the damn place.  It's not going to be much of a mystery as to how those cops got mutilated. smile

Re: Attack the Block

That's a good point. You know, because the events of this film are so claustrophobic and more intimate, it seems kind of microcosmic and we forget that this was just one, localized bit of the alien invasion taking place. Your suggestion that this was happening all over London (maybe even other parts of the world) could lead to some very interesting sequels or at the very least, some fun fan fiction on the internet. smile I'd like to hope that within those stories, any issues I had with this film would be remedied or nonexistent.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

redxavier wrote:

Yup, I have the same problems with this as Pavlich. We're forced to 'protagonise' these vile, loathsome shits, and not nearly enough of them are mauled horribly by the creatures.

Yeah, because everyone everywhere ever has complete control over the environment in which they come in to existence. Gah.

Thumbs up +3 Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

Who shot who in the what now?

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

I'm sure quite a few people got shot in what-now where these guys grew up.

ZangrethorDigital.ca

Re: Attack the Block

Still, I can't help but think this is the kind of thinking that turns potentially good movies into Elysiums.

"So my pitch is about a guy, sort of a criminal really, who's living under a regime that keeps the entire planet in poverty and ensures that only the wealthiest people get proper medical care - "

" And in the end he sacrifices himself to make sure everyone on the planet has perfect health forever?   I LOVE IT.  Green light!"

"Actually I was gonna say 'and in the end one little poor girl gets cured of cancer and they get away to live another day'.  But your way is good, too."

Re: Attack the Block

I've never understood the people who flat out refuse to sympathize with the kids in this movie. How are they any different from the street kids on The Wire? Institutions and circumstances breed codes of conduct in people growing up in those environments, it's not that hard of a concept to wrap your head around. Frankly, not having squeaky clean protagonists is one of the best things this movie has going for it and gives it a unique edge that you wouldn't expect going in. They're forced to face the consequences of their actions, while still getting to be heroes to the neighborhood. I'm sorry the fun throwback B-sci-fi movie doesn't end with a sentencing hearing for 30 minutes so we can see them punished for all their bad behavior  roll

Thumbs up +2 Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

So I've never seen this movie. In fact, of all the movies FIYH has covered that I've never seen, this is the one I know least about. Someone give me the one-sentence pitch.

"The Doctor is Submarining through our brains." --Teague

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

http://the-unexplained-world.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/history-channel-hd-aliens-thumb.jpg

Re: Attack the Block

Trey wrote:

http://the-unexplained-world.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/history-channel-hd-aliens-thumb.jpg

+

http://www.reactionface.info/sites/default/files/images/1345834178446.jpg

=

http://tinyheroes.files.wordpress.com/2011/12/attack-the-block.jpg

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

It's as if I said, "This sandwich is okay, but it's a little dry. Not enough mayo for me." And some are hearing, "Not only do I hate this sandwich like I hate Hitler, but I hate every and all sandwiches that aren't made exactly the same way I want." So, folks just come back at me with, "Well, I'm sorry your sandwich isn't soaked in greasy, high fat mayonnaise, Buddy! But of course it's not. A sandwich slathered in that shit would be disgusting, especially if they were all like that." smile

I'm simply saying the movie tried to have its cake and eat it, too and that didn't work for me. If it's possible for a movie to have it both ways, I just don't feel this one did that successfully. And besides, I already said I LIKE the movie.

It's not that I refuse to sympathize with these kids, it's that I tried to and ultimately can't, especially when the movie shows me some stuff near the end and goes, "See? Sad, right? Don't you just feel bad for them and like them?" My answer is, "Sorry, but no. It's not enough for me." But as I said before, my bigger issue is that the movie seems to be saying, "It's okay to aspire to be a thug. Look how cute these kids are and yay, they get to be in a gang! That's a good thing!"

And no, I wouldn't want a 30-minute court-room scene where the kids are punished, either. That would be too "After School Special." I'm asking for some kind of balance. I've not seen The Wire, so I don't know if the street kids there are different from the ones here. My view on this applies to this movie, not all movies like this because it's not the same. Not all movies are created equal. Presentation and execution count for a lot.

I can sympathize with an "unlikable" character or an "antagonizing" character or one that isn't squeaky clean (Dr. House and Walter White, for example). It's when the characters don't take any responsibility for the bad choices they make and try to pass themselves off as a victim of circumstance or a product of environment, that they've lost my interest or sympathy. Yes, these things are important and do play a role, but they're not the only thing going on. At some point, it falls to you and your decisions on which path to take, when more than one path becomes available.

For example, I had to stop watching Weeds because once Nancy leaves that expensive neighborhood, the show should be over. There's no good reason for her to continue to produce and sell pot and put herself and her family in danger. After that, I checked out because I knew any sympathy I had for that character was going to go away and I would start to resent her, dislike her and I would no longer get enjoyment out of the show anymore. At least, not enough to keep committing to it.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

Teague wrote:

Oops. Sorry, Zap. I must have been thinking of Switzerland.

holden

http://cdn.memegenerator.net/instances/400x/24240604.jpg

God loves you!

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

Teague wrote:

Oops. Sorry, Zap. I must have been thinking of Switzerland.

holden

You probably did - however, googlinating the statistics of this taught me that we have WAY more guns in Sweden than I knew of, and that we actually rank in the top 10 (or top 5, depending on who's counting!!) of gun ownership. Tefuk!? I thought we were the "no guns anywhere pacifist laid back people"?

Yes, lots and lots and lots and lots of hunting rifles. But still. Damn.

We gots that much gunses?

Dayum.

/Z

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

Pavlish: I think the whole part of these kids being unsympathetic tossers is part of the satire of the whole movie, really... that's how I read it.

/Z

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

Half an hour in. Can't believe Americans are dissin European food. Coming from the country tourists have to de-toxify from after they leave. Not all food has to be injection-moulded high fructose corn syrup. big_smile

not long to go now...

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

paulou wrote:

Yeah, because everyone everywhere ever has complete control over the environment in which they come in to existence. Gah.

Everyone can use their environmental circumstances to rationalise their actions, it doesn't mean it's right or justified though. "My rich daddy ignored me", "my mother died when I was young", "I didn't get given that toy when I was 9", "I went to an underfunded school", "my parents are useless layabouts who do drugs all day" are ultimately the same in the eyes of the victim. That doesn't given license to then victimise others. Sociopaths are sociopaths. The vast majority of the downtrodden don't go around behaving in the same way.

And I imagine that the extent of one's sympathy towards these kids is dependent upon one's distance from the reality. Because I bet you everyone wouldn't give two shits of sympathy if a film about arab terrorists saving the world during an alien invasion was released.

It's been a while since I saw it, but do any of the characters actually feel remorse or guilt for mugging the woman outside of the fact that she's poor and similar to them? Doesn't that imply that the film thinks it's ok to rob rich or well to do people who don't live in your neighbourhood?

Imagination will often carry us to worlds that never were. But without it we go nowhere. - Carl Sagan

Thumbs up 0 Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

redxavier wrote:

The vast majority of the downtrodden don't go around behaving in the same way.

That's true, but the statistics normally do show that people raised in socioeconomically depressed areas have lower social mobility, shorter longevity, fewer job prospects, and higher crime rates and other dysfunctionalities, compared to comfortable middle class households.

Environment clearly plays a factor if you zoom out and look at crime nation-wide over decades. It doesn't excuse any individual crimes towards victims, and everyone's still responsible for their actions. The correlation of class and antisocial behaviour helps illuminate the issues if you really want to do something about it. If you truly care about the victims and want to stop the cycle of violence perpetuating itself, then taking the environment into account for the big picture/long game is  necessary. The ultra-libertarian "just deal with it" is not a very sophisticated response.

not long to go now...

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

avatar wrote:

Half an hour in. Can't believe Americans are dissin European food.

We were dissing specific meal experiences, not the cuisine of an entire continent. smile

Re: Attack the Block

For the record, last year I went on vacation -- er, holiday -- to Ireland and I was all about the full breakfast.

Thumbs up +1 Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

From the Adam and Joe Show-

Joe Cornish's proposed theme to Quantum Of Solace-

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

Replaced the file with a normal-quality one, now. 150 megs or so.

Teague Chrystie

I have a tendency to fix your typos.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

Really like this movie, it's a kind of storytelling that's hugely compelling, situational, compressed in time and space, and, dare I say, gritty. Falling in line with Dredd, as mentioned, and other greats like Die Hard and Alien. Gremlins, Tremors and Critters comes to mind of films in a similar vein, "fun" alien invations smile

And The popping CMYK palette is absolutely gorgous!

As for the likeability of the characters I would offer that them being kids, from a shitty neighbourhood gets them a long way from being totally abhorable. I think I took them for common bratty kids, just cranked up a notch by their environment. I have a feeling this movie is largely more conducive to being read into than out of though.

For me the movie's greatest flaw is Moses, I don't believe in him as a real character, and I don't think he really is. He's largely a device used to contrive a more clearly painted theme upon the story than it really needed. Then possibly this device also reflects badly on the rest of the characters as they are painted, as some here suggest, in a somewhat more heroic light than they deserve and it ends up ringing false, which I think is a large reason for the divided opinions. Though you could argue that this is told from the kids' point of view I guess, but it's still somewhat messy storytelling. But I'm not sure you really need to like these characters as much as the film seemingly wants you to, as evidenced by the device, and for some the device had the opposite effect. Maybe without it the characters would actually be more likable (?)

Taking a deep breath.

I wonder if, or probably believe, the reason why movies with compressed time and space often are so compelling is that they usually, by their very nature, need less setups and exposision throughout, we do away with all that swiftly at the start and then you just go!

The Low Frequenter

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

Teague wrote:

Yeah, I'm seeing if anyone minds me reigning in the file size. This one is 46 megs, Contagion was 140.

As someone who iphone downloads and doesn't always have access to wifi when on the road, smaller file sizes
are very welcome.

--
One Time @ Bland Camp...

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Attack the Block

I can't believe the controversy around this. I just watched it and loved it. Great action, pacing, and humor.

The boys have a terrific arc, especially Moses. They start out as street punks who admire Ron, and they end up completely rejecting Ron and embracing the heroism of courage, even the young boys. They change as much as you can realistically hope for them to, and the film makers allow that that might not be enough in the long run. Fantastic.

And as social commentary, it kind of says "Look, these are irredeemable people, most of them. They really just need somewhere positive to channel their energy."

Warning: I'm probably rewriting this post as you read it.

Zarban's House of Commentaries

Re: Attack the Block

Zarban wrote:

And as social commentary, it kind of says "Look, these are irredeemable people, most of them. They really just need somewhere positive to channel their energy."

If all they need is a positive place to channel their energy, doesn't that mean they are basically redeemable?

ZangrethorDigital.ca