Topic: The last 'Perfect' Movie?
We're gathered here because we love movies. We love the craft, the escapism, the spectacle, Plato's shadows on a cave wall, etc.
But in the last few years, there's been just as much anguish and ambivalence. We also hate movies - the bland remakes, nothing-but-superheroes, too many zombies and vampires, the overuse of CG, the by-the-numbers construction, the hacks, the hams, the shoddy storytelling, the disrespect for the material, etc.
So the question is, when was the last 'Perfect' movie? When every set-up paid off to end satisfactorily? When all the elements clicked: the casting, the score, the screenplay, the effects. Ideally the perfect movie will have surprises, yet be re-watchable many times. It'll usually have depth and heart and ideas as well as spectacle. It'll push the envelope of the craft in some new direction. It'll have something iconic (a performance, a line, a scene) that leaps over into pop culture. Often a perfect movie will also both have mainstream and cult respect, giving it a combination of box office and critical success.
There are plenty of examples 'Perfect' movies from the past: Raiders, Back to the Future, Star Wars, Terminator 1&2, Alien(s), Jurassic Park, Pirates 1, Fight Club.
When was the last movie to join those classics?
I was thinking maybe The Dark Knight. It ticks a lot of boxes. But it lacks a little heart and tries to compress two movies' worth of plot into its running time.
So I'm going to nominate The Return of the King. It delivers on every level, and no movie since then has matched it.