I always have two top five lists. The first one is my personal favorites, geeking out included, that I've spent the most time thinking about since viewing them. The second list are the actual best cinematic experiences of the year. These are the ones that get me excited as a filmmaker. That's still subjective, of course, but there's a little less 'omg Superman's so cool' involved in the decisions.
So, of what I saw this year, which is not nearly as much as I'd intended to, my personal faves:
5) Ender's Game
4) The Wolverine
3) Oblivion
2) Catching Fire
1) Man of Steel
I'm honestly not prepared to make the second list because I saw so few of the films I think would deserve to be on it. Gravity and Oblivion, for sure. Probably American Hustle, too. Side Effects.
Eh, that's almost five. I'd probably say The Great Gatsby if they'd cast anyone but Tobey Maguire. That just totally killed the mood for me, IIRC everything else was superb.
"Defending bad movies is VaporTrail's religion."
-DorkmanScott