Topic: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

What did y'all think? It's on Netflix streaming, for us ugly Americans.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

Must.....refrain...... from.......bashing......George

not long to go now...

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

just a quick question; is there a story in the prequeals?

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

Yeah.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

5 (edited by Squiggly_P 2012-05-28 18:28:07)

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

I have about a page worth of hate for Lucas that has nothing at all to do with ruining star wars or indy or whatever. They're movies. Get over it.

No, I hate George Lucas because he's a hack and a con artist and a fucking asshole.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

Thumbs up +1 Thumbs down

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

I have to say, I have more irrational hatred for Chris Gore than for Lucas, so hearing his name come up as one of those in the documentary was a bit jarring smile Not just did Film Threat magazine get on my nerves, but then Gore becomes editor of the best computer and video game magazine and runs it into the ground! At least Lucas only ruined his own stuff!

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

Who is Chris Gore and why do you hate him?

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

Chris Gore founded this old magazine called Film Threat, which in its day, was pretty good.  But once websites like Aint it Cool, Dark Horizons, and CHUD became the go to place for film news, Film Threat died a slow and painful death before becoming web exclusive itself.  He wrote, admittedly, a pretty solid film festival book called Ultimate Film Festival Survivor guide.  If you had films in Festivals in the late 90's/early Aughts, this book was pretty mandatory reading.  Now that Festivals have changed so thoroughly though, he clings to whatever bits of fame he can.  He appears regularly on G4, and at fringe industry parties making an ass out of himself.  I've met him a few times, and there was on time at the GPhoria Awards 2005, where he would drunkenly come up to me every 30 minutes and ask if Amy Earhart (star of Pink 5) was coming to the party or not.

He's fairly harmless these days, but if you ever need a sound bite from a gray hair dude in hipster clothes, he's your guy.

Eddie Doty

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

I must admit, my irrational hatred mostly comes from the magazine Video Games and Computer Entertainment. It was a great read, aimed at the more, if not intelligent, then at least non 8 year old market. Gore comes in as editor, and suddenly it's all cheat codes, big print, and even dropping all coverage of computers. Makes you cry.

Film Threat was fun, when I was a teen, but I soured on it about the time The Crow came out. The magazine had done a review of the work print of the film shown just after Brandon Lee's death, trashing it... then, when the actual movie came out (you know, the thing that wasn't just an assemblage of rough footage) it got praised to high heaven with no mention of the previous review. I gave up on the magazine not long after that.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

Ah gotcha!

I think I've actually got that Film Festival book somewhere...

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

To be fair, the videogame magazine business went that way all at once, not just VG&CE. A LOT of magazines did that around the same time and paid the price. RIP Next Generation, tho EDGE lives on and is still pretty decent. Not as good as it used to be, tho. There were a few teams who basically said "no, we don't want to make an EGM or PC Gamer clone, we want to keep doing this our way", and those people got their magazines outright cancelled. It was more of a publisher thing than an editorial one.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

So what you guys are saying is that you've been living & breathing prequel-hate for 15 years, so you're over it. Through the looking glass. Level 10.

Level 1. What's Star Wars?
Level 2. Oh, I've heard of Star Wars. They're cool movies.
Level 3. The OT is great, the prequels suck!
Level 4. Let's discuss endlessly how the prequels suck
Level 5. Let's discuss endlessly how the prequels can be improved
Level 6. Lucas raped my childhood and I'm going to break into Skywalker Ranch and demand reparations and a re-edit
Level 7. Whatever George. Star Wars is now ruined, from the juvenile special editions to the infantile prequels to the cartoons to the whored-out-to-anyone over-commercialization.
Level 8. Burns all Star Wars stuff in a funeral pyre and says an an anguished good bye.
Level 9. The pain is fading, the memory is dim. No longer care if Jar Jar is inserted everywhere into the OT and the next Star Wars movie was a Jar Jar origin story.
10. What's Star Wars?

From the comments on this forum over the years, some people are on various points on this continuum. Perhaps it's analogous to Malcolm Gladwell's 10,000 hours idea. You gotta do x amount of hours of grieving before you're out the other side.

not long to go now...

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

I'm at a wierd combination of levels 6 & 7.    sad

"Life is about movies; anything else is a bonus!"- Me   cool

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

"I'm gonna make a prequel and a sequel for THX1138 in 3D that will both be better than the first one. I originally wrote the story that way, but I only had enough money to make the middle part..."

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

Those who would trade liberties for securities, deserve neither liberties, nor securities.
-Benjamin Franklin

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

Congrats on your imminent fatherhood.

Thumbs up +1 Thumbs down

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

not long to go now...

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

Those who would trade liberties for securities, deserve neither liberties, nor securities.
-Benjamin Franklin

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

Hey look at this.

Ridley Scott, same as George Lucas.

Killed a perfectly good (2 ep.) franchise with poor prequel.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

At least when he puts out a new version of one of his movies he doesn't try to deny the previous ones exist.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

Re: #33 - The People vs. The People vs. George Lucas

not long to go now...

Thumbs up Thumbs down