Re: Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon
It does come back to what exactly the myth was they were testing
Yes. This was my problem with the test. The parameters of the myth was, is it humanly possible to catch an arrow. Not "under battle conditions" or anything like that. Just was it possible, full stop, to have the reflexes necessary to catch an arrow out of the air.
The original test was a robot hand that they set up with average grip strength and reaction time. This "battle conditions" shit came straight out of left field and had nothing to do with the original parameters of the myth. So the myth was plausible, if not confirmed, and then they created this straw man version out of thin air, pretended they'd been testing that, and called it busted.
I didn't want to say this on the recording, but I happened to run into Adam Savage backstage at last year's Comic Con, told him I was a giant fan, and proceeded to lay into him about the ninja catching an arrow myth, totally ruining my chances of ever having a personal hero of mine think that I was cool. That's how insane that episode makes me.
Tory was also there, and he thought it was funny.
If I run into Adam at TAM (which I am going to this year, what what) I will pretend that it never happened and see if he ever makes the connection. He meets so many people I've probably got a second chance at a first impression.