That's a good point, but on The Cowboys it didn't bother me that they hadn't read the book. Here, I think, is the difference: The commentary for The Cowboys mostly approaches the movie from the context of it being a western and thus them being knowledgeable about the book wasn't nearly as important as them being knowledgeable about other westerns. For Scott Pilgrim they spend a lot of time talking about the movie in the context of it being an adaption from a comic, so none of them having actually read the comic felt particularly egregious. They might have been able to avoid it by not talking about the comic at all, but being an adaption from a comic is a significant part of that film's identity, so avoiding talking about it probably would have felt really awkward.

I'm still kinda mad at them for doing the Scott Pilgrim movie without having a single person who'd read the comics on the panel. Instead they just kinda speculated about what the comics might be like the whole time and the commentary suffers for it.

Teague, this album better not turn out to be another Tydirium.

I'm not saying they should have added Nova, that would have been a mistake, but what they did do doesn't really work either, and as long as we're fucking up, I'd rather we got Nova. What would be better would be something along the lines of what Squiggly_P was suggesting. I also think it would have been fine to have some Nova Centurions flying around in the battle so if they do want to introduce Nova later it would make more sense. I think people are familiar enough with the Marvel universe by now that we can have some superpowered guys in the background without too much explanation.

These are pretty good. Really digging the second one. You should make more.

Hey Teague, look at this guy, he actually released some music. 

You just nostalgia'd me so hard. Now I want to play Yoda Stories again, even though it kinda sucked.

The discussion about mkeith's line return habits reminded me of when the whole forum was hard constrained to 600px wide. It was such a pain in the ass to read that I actually got off my ass and convinced Teague to let me fix it. Now I kinda wish it would stretch out to 1200px instead of just 1000, but then it wouldn't line up with the header all nice and that would bother me so I'd have to fix that too and it all starts to sound like more work then it's worth. Non of this is particularly relevant, but it looks like we're fairly off topic anyway.