701

(43 replies, posted in Episodes)

NPR did a good segment on Bioshock Infinite arguing that it's art (note though if you're playing through it and want to be totally unspoiled, I recommend waiting till you finish, it doesn't spoil any details but hints at where it's going in broad strokes): http://www.npr.org/blogs/alltechconside … ragic-play

They similarly have a really good interview with the game's creator Ken Levine: http://onpoint.wbur.org/2013/04/02/bioshock

Having played through it myself, I certainly think it qualifies and put it on the level of the "smarter" blockbuster a la Inception or the Prestige. Like in those movies there's logical leaps, but the scale and ambition of what it tries to do is so awesome, that I can mostly forgive it. In fact, I'd say its stronger than Inception, because the overarching story of the world and the character's personal journey are well tied together thematically, whereas Inception's overall plot about competing oil company executives is largely pointless.

That's judged against the tougher standards of the film medium though. Judged against other video game narratives, which are almost uniformly terrible (at best they just successfully ripoff an existing movie, see Uncharted = Indiana Jones, at worst they're completely non-existent), it's a fucking masterwork. That they managed to spend 4 years and 100+ million dollars and make a game that feels this personal, detailed, and thematically rich, is crazy.

702

(39 replies, posted in Creations)

Very impressive, but ya, its clearly a story begging for a longer run-time, I can see how hard it must've been to try to compress that to 7 min. I think the interesting part of the story to me would be Ralph's own perspective and reasoning on the whole thing. Kind of like the way The Imposter handled its story.
What drives a guy into trying to pull off a deception like that, what's his perspective on it at this point. Also, for a guy that seemed to be so nice and welcoming to everyone, what drove him to murder.

Really think this could make an amazing feature length doc, or an hour long that would fit right in with Espn's 30 for 30 series.

703

(649 replies, posted in Off Topic)

I like the idea a lot, would be happy to participate at some point

704

(31 replies, posted in Off Topic)

Damnit, this is the worst. It's not like he slowly aged and was losing it, he was still on top of his game and juggling like 6 different projects, and a week later, dead. just fuck this

705

(473 replies, posted in Episodes)

Republic Commando is the last big really good release off the top of my head, that was 05, so ya, 7 or 8, you're right. Still a long damned while. They really seemed to start dropping the ball when the next-gen systems hit. They never ended up releasing a proper Indiana Jones game for ps3/xbox360, which seems to me like a sure-fire winner, and basically let Uncharted steal their thunder. They also completely abandoned the Space Sim genre, which they had been kings of for the past decade, and let a whole bunch of similar opportunities slip by.

RIP for the glory days though, they truly made some of the finest PC games of the 90s, most of which still hold up today.

706

(473 replies, posted in Episodes)

Ya, I'd feel more sad about Lucasarts closing if they'd done anything worth a damn in the last 10 years.
The people who were responsible for their most amazing stuff, like Grim Fandango and Tie Fighter and Jedi Knight have largely moved on, and they've been pushing out crap like Kinect Star Wars. If anything the licensing approach might actually lead to some good games for a change as more people get to take a crack at it.

707

(49 replies, posted in Episodes)

Fuck this movie just based on its aesthetics, I cannot stand those costume and makeup choices. I don't care if its there for a reason, get it off my screen.

708

(64 replies, posted in Episodes)

Eddie wrote:

That article has largely been dismkssed by everyone.

Ya, shame on me for trusting bloody disgusting on something. There is a definite degree of being painted into a corner though, I see no way to continue that story with those characters in a way that would make me give a shit. If they do go for a sequel they need to do something completely different.

709

(64 replies, posted in Episodes)

Hahaha, and now Fox and Ridley have no idea what to do for a sequel because they fucked it up so bad on the first movie: http://bloody-disgusting.com/news/32253 … -lindelof/

710

(48 replies, posted in Episodes)

Ya, I would absolutely listen to a weekly thing like this, that was super cool.

Also there's a potential for a Whose Line is it Anyway style music improv show.

711

(46 replies, posted in Episodes)

I find they tend to color it wrong. I actually think Dredd gets the color right, they're kind of bright redish, whereas most digital squibs nowadays are a really bad looking dark brown (possibly for rating reasons). I want my Paul Verhoeven bright red exploding squibs goddamnit! Also, for the record, I believe Dredd uses mostly practical squibs based on the behind the scenes stuff I've seen, with maybe some enhancement, or replacement for the really flashy sequences.

712

(48 replies, posted in Episodes)

It'd be good if it wasn't following up a series that has some of the most iconic sci-fi music of the last 40 years, to which it doesn't even come close. Opinions are gonna be subjective no matter what, but to me it's a kinda weak main theme when you stack it up against Horner's and Goldsmith's work, it doesn't convey the wonder and sense of exploration that I think it should.

The opening theme of Up collectively made half the grown men in america cry in a 5 minute span, so it absolutely deserved the nomination and win (it won right?).

713

(48 replies, posted in Episodes)

Worst Williams score is undoubtedly Kingdom of the Crystal Skull.
Best non-lucas/Spielberg is Superman.

I'm baffled at your defense of the Star Trek reboot score, but the Incredibles soundtrack is undoubtedly fucking great.
With all the videogame talk, wish Jeremy Soule had gotten a shoutout.

Other than that, an amazing episode. Like I seriously would listen to a weekly version of that panel.

714

(48 replies, posted in Episodes)

This might be the best episode of DIF.

I believe the script opens with him being deposed from the throne (probably for being a terrible ruler) and left for dead, at which point mercenaries come after him. I know Karl Urban filmed a small cameo, so I'm guessing this all happens in the first 5 minutes and then we're on to a pitch-black style adventure.

Ya, I was optimistic because the Taken unrated cut is actually excellent, and VASTLY better than the awful cut down US release, but no dice on this one.

Nope, watched the unrated cut, there's basically nothing added back in.

I think it's pretty weak. The pg-13 really cripples it, there's nothing memorable about it in terms of action. You'd think an action movie on a space station would be awesome, but they don't do a lot with it.

Semi-related, I checked out Olympus has Fallen, the first of 2 Die Hard on a White House movies this year, and it's frustratingly mediocre. There's sections where it's ripping off Die Hard whole-sale that actually work quite well, but then there's other stuff that's just terrible. Cheesy ass patriotic music straight out of West Wing, the worst theatrically released CGI I've ever seen (seriously Asylum quality stuff), and a pretty sloppy screenplay.

It does make good use of its R-rating though, it goes a lot more brutal than you'd expect from this kinda movie (at least 50 people get shot or stabbed in the head throughout). That's what's annoying about it, there's pieces of it that are totally the 80s/90s throwback I want it to be, but not enough of it to overcome the bad stuff. Will be interesting to compare with White House Down in 3 months though, if only academically.

719

(22 replies, posted in Episodes)

For my money, the white house attack opening of X2 is the best thing in any of the x-men movies, and probably the best sequence Bryan Singer has ever directed. The rest of X2 just isn't quite as strong for me (Singer just isn't a very good action director, so a lot of the climax feels kinda small), but it's still the best in the series overall.

720

(364 replies, posted in Episodes)

Total Recall is in many ways the balls out last blast of the 80s, a cartoony, ambitious, awesome hard-R rated action movie done pretty much entirely with practical effects (most of which hold up really well). A year later Terminator 2 would come out and change everything, and we'd be subjected to 5-10 years of awful CG effects work as people tried and failed to duplicate Cameron's success.

721

(364 replies, posted in Episodes)

I'm baffled that Teague and Dorkman can not appreciate Predator, it's like the best version of a Schwarzenegger action movie crossed with an awesome science fiction story. The music, the action direction, the VFX work.
You should force them to appreciate it like you did with Unforgiven (though that one took like 3 years, so we can expect Predator in like 2016).

722

(349 replies, posted in Off Topic)

Why do people love Game of Thrones?...cause it's fucking awesome:

723

(62 replies, posted in Episodes)

I just rewatched it last night and I still love the hell out of it, but there are valid criticisms one can bring up.

The core problem is that it's not at all successful as a horror movie, until maybe the last 20 minutes (which really make the movie in my opinion). Of all the monsters they could go with for the "movie within the movie" section, zombies just seem like such a lame copout. If you seriously just replaced them with werewolves, or something cooler, I think the movie immediately gets stronger and works better in its genre. Without that, much of the movie ends up feeling like a Spoof movie, there's a degree of sincerity missing.

I think an interesting comparison point would be Scream (and this is a movie I'd really like to see a DIF on at some point), because that film largely does all the same genre deconstruction of Cabin in the Woods, but it's still a very effective horror film with some really harrowing and intense sequences. It's both an excellent slasher movie, and an excellent meta-commentary on slashers, whereas I think Cabin nails the commentary, but doesn't really work on a thriller level. Scream also did all this almost 20 years ago, so it's funny to see Cabin in the Woods talked about like some revolutionary thing that's never been tried before.

That being said, I think the writing in Cabin is outstanding, I think all the character setups, interactions, and payoffs are excellent, and I find it very rewatchable (its also EXACTLY 90 minutes long, which is nice).

I cannot stop watching this, it's amazing

725

(64 replies, posted in Episodes)

Todo list: Edit out 95% of the dialogue in Prometheus and turn it into a 45 minute art film

Also found this: http://www.fanedit.org/ifdb/component/c … giftbearer

Would almost be curious to give that a watch and see if it holds together better, the change list is extensive