726

(3 replies, posted in Off Topic)

You make some good points; how would you compare this season with the last? Did you have similar criticisms about season 2? I've seen a fair amount of praise for this new one, and I imagine a lot of that is due to the marked improvement in pacing and writing compared to season 2. It's not perfect, Michonne indeed hasn't really been developed and her muteness seems to exist to prevent the plot from moving forwards at times. But still, what an improvement over the wreck that was season 2! Where we had characters engaging in contrived conflicts and playing with the idiot ball, mirred in a dragged out and uninteresting search for a lost member of their group.

I can't say I agree with you about Rick. He had a breakdown, born of guilt and grief, it happens and he's recovered (somewhat). I think it makes him more interesting, rather than the typical unflappable leader.

What I dislike most about this season, and one that started in season 2, has been Andrea. She's thoroughly unlikeable and her storylines are unconvincing. It feels like early in the show's development the actress suggested playing her sassy, but instead she just looks pissed and bitchy; maybe it's sort of snowballed from there. Given what she does in this third series, her character's so far removed from the comic she can never can get back there.

Most of my complaints about the show stem from the divergences from the comic and a sense that, with few exceptions, it's an inferior telling of the story. I find The Walking Dead to be probably one of the most surprising and well written comics out there.

727

(359 replies, posted in Off Topic)

It's certainly a teaser! I'm quite impressed that they managed to show me all this footage and restrain themselves from revealing any of the story (I've not read anything about it so can't also put it into any context).

I have no feelings about it at the moment, it does look quite action-y, but no doubt I'll be there in line when it gets released.

731

(316 replies, posted in Episodes)

I hope to see it as 'normally' as possible. But on a side note, I can't believe we're here already, the release of the film a mere week away. Seems like only the other day this was mirred in legal action hell.

733

(165 replies, posted in Off Topic)

734

(165 replies, posted in Off Topic)

735

(473 replies, posted in Episodes)

I would love to see a series of animated films based on the various popular existing EU stories, imagine Shadows of the Empire or the Thrawn Trilogy fully animated with the voices of the actual actors?

736

(165 replies, posted in Off Topic)

I can't really envision a joke with rape as the punchline, let alone imagine it to be a funny. Oh well, I guess I just don't know 'funny' like Pactrice O'Neal (who I'd never heard of before).

And of course being offended is exhausting and you have things to do, that's why I advise only being offended about actual things that matter in your personal life, not knee jerk over generalizations on the internet like the Tony Harris post that have been twisted through projection. Most of the time, people get offended over the tiniest of things that have little to no bearing on them, stuff that they wouldn't even know about until someone else told them they should be offended.

737

(261 replies, posted in Episodes)

I don't think there's actually any disagreement that you owe something, but the question could be 'what do you owe'? Just throwing this idea out there, I'm not saying I know the answer or if there even is one.

Obviously, our economy is way too complicated, and our lives too overburdened, to have a reciprocal service scheme (AKA you make me a spear and I'll sew you a wolfskin cloak). What did the communists do? Were all accomplishments just put in a well and then anyone could retrieve from that well whatever else they needed? I'm not sure welfare is practical given the size of populations these days...

738

(165 replies, posted in Off Topic)

739

(261 replies, posted in Episodes)

740

(316 replies, posted in Episodes)

741

(261 replies, posted in Episodes)

742

(27 replies, posted in Movie Stuff)

And we have eyes  wink

743

(261 replies, posted in Episodes)

I for one have to commend TheGreg for his arguments against allcomers. I don't necessarily agree with everthing he says, but he posts interesting food for thought.

I'm somewhat disappointed by the taste of some of the analogies being used. Are we sure we couldn't think of better ways to illustrate and support our arguments?

744

(316 replies, posted in Episodes)

Remembering Lost just makes me angry. If I ever watch it again, I'll end it when they open that hatch and just assume they unleashed the smoke monster that then killed them all. That's a better ending to anything they could have come up with and at least I won't have to suffer through inane plots, stupid characters who never talk to each other, pointless literature and pop culture references thrown in to make the audience feel clever, and a thousand and one further mysteries thrown in just to keep viewers coming back every week.

With regards to your point above Hansen regarding having a detailed story plan being overrated - I can't say I agree, especially if your story relies on a big mystery or central mythology. Of the 4 shows I'm aware of that have such a mystery at their heart that I've seen, all have failed to deliver on those expectations generated when they began it - X-Files, ALIAS, Lost, and BSG - and we know all of them didn't actually have an answer in place before they started down that road. Furthermore, another initially successful TV show, Heroes, then went completely off the rails because the subsequent seasons, which they hadn't planned for at all, were rushed into production. The record isn't good.

The 'making it up as you go along' can only work if you're really fucking good at writing and/or you know your material really well. The most successful multi-arc series of them, Babylon 5, is masterful in how well connected all the bits are - season 1 is a text-book example of how to lay the groundwork and every season expands and extends beautifully. But not all of it was set in stone, and JMS routinely had to negotiate ways of getting through major obstacles such as actors leaving the show. But then... that was his skill and planning as well, he had written 'trap doors' for all of his characters which allowed him alternative stories should they leave.

745

(316 replies, posted in Episodes)

746

(28 replies, posted in Off Topic)

747

(27 replies, posted in Movie Stuff)

I thought the motorcycle chase on the rooftops was pretty poorly done, something about the compositing on the close-ups made it look very fake.

748

(64 replies, posted in Off Topic)

749

(64 replies, posted in Off Topic)

750

(165 replies, posted in Off Topic)