You make some good points; how would you compare this season with the last? Did you have similar criticisms about season 2? I've seen a fair amount of praise for this new one, and I imagine a lot of that is due to the marked improvement in pacing and writing compared to season 2. It's not perfect, Michonne indeed hasn't really been developed and her muteness seems to exist to prevent the plot from moving forwards at times. But still, what an improvement over the wreck that was season 2! Where we had characters engaging in contrived conflicts and playing with the idiot ball, mirred in a dragged out and uninteresting search for a lost member of their group.
I can't say I agree with you about Rick. He had a breakdown, born of guilt and grief, it happens and he's recovered (somewhat). I think it makes him more interesting, rather than the typical unflappable leader.
What I dislike most about this season, and one that started in season 2, has been Andrea. She's thoroughly unlikeable and her storylines are unconvincing. It feels like early in the show's development the actress suggested playing her sassy, but instead she just looks pissed and bitchy; maybe it's sort of snowballed from there. Given what she does in this third series, her character's so far removed from the comic she can never can get back there.
Most of my complaints about the show stem from the divergences from the comic and a sense that, with few exceptions, it's an inferior telling of the story. I find The Walking Dead to be probably one of the most surprising and well written comics out there.










