Good arguments all. It's a fascinating discussion, and the stuff about the Berne Convention is really interesting. I once wanted to go into copyright law.
Trey - I meant genuine criminals as in organised crime. You can bet if it's profitable servers will be set up in Eastern Europe countries where they'll be mafia running the show.
DoctorSubmarine - I'm afraid I disagree, downloading is not theft. I don't believe the law considers it such either. It's a crime yes, because you are infringing on the owner's right of reproduction (downloading is the creation of a copy). That's distinct from the taking of property and is such not theft.










