976

(74 replies, posted in Episodes)

Good arguments all. It's a fascinating discussion, and the stuff about the Berne Convention is really interesting. I once wanted to go into copyright law.

Trey - I meant genuine criminals as in organised crime. You can bet if it's profitable servers will be set up in Eastern Europe countries where they'll be mafia running the show.

DoctorSubmarine - I'm afraid I disagree, downloading is not theft. I don't believe the law considers it such either. It's a crime yes, because you are infringing on the owner's right of reproduction (downloading is the creation of a copy). That's distinct from the taking of property and is such not theft.

977

(1,019 replies, posted in Episodes)

I'm curious, what the first two kinds of close encounters? I always wondered whether that confused people. They did, after all, drop the III from The 'Madness of King George' to avoid baffling folk.

978

(74 replies, posted in Episodes)

The difference to theft is that you are not actually taking property, you're reproducing it. It's copyright infringement. And that doesn't sound catchy or damaging at all.

With regards to security, it's certainly a factor these days because of the open nature of exchanged data, especially between companies. It's pointless for studios to worry about people sneaking into cinemas with camcorders and try to police horrible camversions of theatrically released films all while the VFX effects, DVD authoring and PR people who work on the film post-production handle the material so insensitively, bringing it home to work on or sharing it with their friends and family. That's where those pristine early copies come from.

Isn't that akin, using your analogy, of giving someone a gun and blaming them when they shoot you?

Anyway, whoever heard of a book being pirated until they became digitilised? I've no idea why all these organisations aren't going after the manufacturers of the tools that enable piracy in the first place.

979

(74 replies, posted in Episodes)

Owen Ward wrote:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-16642369

There goes Megaupload!

Nonsensical. All this will do is drive filesharing sites to regions where they cannot be touched, where they will then be run by genuine criminals.

Let's shut down dropbox too while we're at. And youtube. And ftp sites. And, oh wait, the internet's gone because the entire world wide web is built upon the principle of exchange of data - ergo a potential means of distributing copyrighted material.

And calculations of 'lost revenue due to online piracy' are bullshit and entirely speculative. It's simply not a case that someone who downloads a film would have otherwise paid to watch it. The real piracy is the bootlegging and selling of actual discs on market streets in Eastern regions, which thus see significantly diminished revenue because no-one is going to the cinema. But fuck all has been done about that since the early 90s.

The solution to all of this is simple. Don't allow your home video formats to be used with computers. If blurays couldn't be played on a computer at all, the ease of pirating them would be drastically reduced. But instead, the PC market appears to actively encourage copying by allowing people to read DVDs and CDs, copy their contents (even using official programs), and then burn them onto very cheap blank DVDs.. at no cost to the original's quality.

Remember in the days of VHS/Betamax when even if you could set up your system to copy (requiring two vhs players), it was a crappy quality version?

And what's more, have some goddamn security at your own offices and don't flood the awards folk with screeners AKA Copy Me.

To my mind, online piracy actually does fuck all to revenue streams, precisely because it's so relatively miniscule, it's just being targeted because it's easy for companies to connect falling revenue to it. Why bother to analyse why people aren't going to cinemas nearly as much as they were 50 years ago when you have an easy scapegoat? Especially when that scapegoat can be mislabelled as stealing.

980

(43 replies, posted in Creations)

Truly beautiful shots so far. I am genuinely inspired.

981

(22 replies, posted in Creations)

Awesome. Imagine my train of thought as I saw the banner for Corinna 'hey where do I recognise that picture from?', 'wait, that's from Corinna', 'hold on, what's it doing there?', 'DiF forum community?', 'oh wow it's pimping a project I worked on!'

Thank you.

982

(1,019 replies, posted in Episodes)

Yup. I've seen a few episodes and I thought it was really enjoyable. It was shortly after the movie was released and I heard about how bad it was - wanted to see whether the source material was really as good as folks were saying.

983

(1,019 replies, posted in Episodes)

I've not seen this one. What do you reckon, should I sample tonight or go in cold tomorrow?

984

(56 replies, posted in Episodes)

Sweet, the DiF team pulled it together for Close Encounters!

985

(9 replies, posted in Off Topic)

When the hell was this? How could this happen a mere hour and change away from me and I not hear about it!

986

(27 replies, posted in Off Topic)

I've just completed 5 years working as an editor for a medical writing agency (we work for various pharmaceutical companies) and now I'm not sure what what to do next. My brother's looking to set up a studio and has invited me to join him, we'd be doing shorts, movies, TV, commercials etc. as well as regular photography. So in 5 years time I suppose my plan is to either have progessed and become a medical writer or be working in the entertainment business/working on a TV show/sitting at the premiere of the hard sci-fi film I'm writing.

987

(173 replies, posted in Episodes)

Interesting, you seem to have 1027 points with that. By my calculation there should be 1022 points total from the 49 voters so far - 21 each minus 6 points since rtambree chose 3 movies not from the list and 1 point by Pfosback who listed Dark Knight twice. I took into consideration the changed votes.

These are my current numbers, the big difference is the Dark Knight's 10 points:
77    Batman Returns (Trey worked on it)
162    The Dark Knight
30    American Beauty
69    Kick-Ass
49    Lethal Weapon
78    The Last Airbender
87    Unforgiven
24    My Favorite Martian (Trey worked on it)
67    Transformers 3
31    Cowboys & Aliens
25    The Happening
81    Who Framed Roger Rabbit?
54    Close Encounters of the Third Kind
51    Citizen Kane
50    The Wizard of Oz
49    Super 8
38    Battlefield Earth

I separated out results by voter, but admit I could have put a vote on the wrong line.

Taking a look at Dark Knight, it was voted for 38 times.
12x 1st place
7x 2nd place
6x 3rd place
8x 4th place
2x 5th place
3x 6th place

I'll send over my spreadsheet at the end.

988

(173 replies, posted in Episodes)

Wow, 49 folks have voted. And what do you know, the top 6 have changed quite a bit since the weekend.
Dark Knight 162
Unforgiven 87
Who Framed Roger Rabbit? 81
Last Airbender 78
Batman Returns 77
Kickass 69

989

(35 replies, posted in Off Topic)

From people who should know better? Transformers 3. I'm geniunely shocked at how this got to release in its current state.

990

(14 replies, posted in Episodes)

Bit late to this, but in my opinion anything done should be geared towards demonstrating passion.
Passion for the project, passion for the story, the characters, the cast and crew. i find that passion can
be infectious.
The flipside is to go for the mystery, the 'no-one can be told what the matrix is, you have
to see it for yourself' idea.

991

(173 replies, posted in Episodes)

Kickass, Close Encounters and Kane are tied at 28 points.

992

(173 replies, posted in Episodes)

Ooh, so exciting!

1. Lethal Weapon (another classic action movie to add to the collection)
2. Unforgiven (beautiful and brutal film, glad you've got this on your list!)
3. Transformers 3 (shooting fish in a barrel!)
4. The Dark Knight
5. American Beauty (I like Road to Perdition more, but this was a great movie)
6. Batman Returns

I confess I've not even seen most of the rest!


By the way, at this moment, Dark Knight is well ahead (63 points), followed by Transformers 3 and Who Framed the Stupid Rabbit? (33 each), Super 8 (30), and then Close Encounters and Citizen Kane (22)*. Come on guys, are you really going to make me watch Citizen Kane again?
*that is, unless I've forked up!

993

(89 replies, posted in Episodes)

Friggin awesome. Not much to say other than that really!

edit - for drinks, just go with ale and mead!

994

(30 replies, posted in Episodes)

I didn't much like this movie. Mainly because the central character is an unlikeable douchebag and the film never seems to know how to handle it. It never seeks to explain why he's acting the way he does and what motivates him - he appears to be a dick because he wants to be. He's a borderline sociopath. The film seems to want to counteract this by making all the people he's up against equally unlikeable. Then at the end the film wants the audience to feel sorry for him, and this was a bit too forced and sudden for my liking.

I've just realised that recently I've been streaming the latest episodes on my android phone, sorry! yikes

996

(4 replies, posted in Off Topic)

In the interviews on the LOTR dvds, he comes across as a charming person. What unfortunate news to start the year off.

997

(80 replies, posted in Episodes)

I always enjoyed this movie as a kid, but it wasn't until I watched it as an adult that I truly understood how great it was. I now got alot of the jokes (particularly Doc's) such as the world's gravity and Reagan as president, that went over my head as a young 'un.

It's a classic, a great, powerful story under the trappings of an exciting and funny adventure.

I really enjoyed this episode of the Intermission, and I'm hoping you do more episodes when you chat about DiF and general stuff (the anniversary episodes only come along once a year after all!).

999

(8 replies, posted in Off Topic)

FireFighter214 wrote:
Invid wrote:

Given a copy of the movie isn't included in the episodes, I don't see the problem. If anything, it gets you to rent movies you wouldn't otherwise want to see.

I'm in agreement with you. But I'm worried with the Entertainment industry having the power, they would have the power to shut down ANY website they feel is even encouraging piracy.  I don't think DIF is doing that but if they do get shut down, DIF has virtually no way to defend itself.

Well, in a twisted sense, by mentioning computer files in the opening (and since most computer versions of movies are downloaded copies) DiF could be argued as 'encouraging' piracy.

1,000

(4 replies, posted in Off Topic)

Same here! Lose weight and do more creative stuff. The short film I wrote is officially a year behind schedule now and my hard sci-fi script has still only got the first page written.

Happy new year!