I know the sound is off, but they have talked about the music in several other commentaries.

I don't plan to see it, but I thought it was worth bringing up to discuss, since I am a fan of the original.  I know its business decision, admittedly its probably a smart one too considering the popularity of the music/teenage genre right now. However, if it's an awful remake, but still makes money that means the studios will make more movies similar to it and push aside projects I would like to see. And since it has MTV attached to it, I have no hope of it being anything resembling quality.

I like this movie; I enjoy it.  My excuse, there were many people out there that applauded at the end of the Transformer movies. However, as soon as a guy took a running leap out of a window while firing pistols, I was no longer taking anything seriously.

I don't care what you say, I will continue to like this movie, however I did enjoy your commentary.

Thank you for doing this movie.  I really enjoy it we I saw it the theater and every time I watch it afterwards.

I also agree with Trey in that adaptions need to be judge as their own works separate from what they are adapted from.  There are things that work on the pages of book that don't work on film and vice-versa. This also holds true with comic books and video games, or whatever else one may adapt from.  They may share the same elements like plot, story, character, etc. but there a things a filmmaker has to do  in order to make a movie work that are different from what authors have to do to make a what they do work.

I really like the addition of Miki. I look forward to what she brings to the table in future commentaries.

But if they were remade, it would only mean billions of more dollars, on second thought, maybe he's had enough and the whole thing would be the cinema equivalent of beating a dead horse.

I agree, Incredibles is my favorite Pixar film.

I just found this, and was wondering if any of you guys have heard about this and what you thought about it.

Did Tarantino just "borrow" heavily from City on Fire, or did he commit out right plagiarism, or does this guy not know what he's talking about?

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/04/3 … 58904.html

Personally, I just think its a heavy homage to City on Fire.

Its kind of wild they managed to make a twilight type movie less interesting by focusing on the opposite character from the Bella type.

Do you think this is going to be released in theaters?