176

(62 replies, posted in Episodes)

So... I don't want to turn into the cheerleader that always posts, "lol, great episode guys!"... But I really liked that one. The film vs. digital debate is sort of fascinating, but having only ever done anything digitally, I only have one side of the argument to draw on. While I liked last week's, having not seen either film I did feel a little shut-out, but this one was much more accessible.

You were talking about how there's going to be a generational split with regard to frame-rates and 360 shutter and all that, but I don't think it's even going to be a case of generation. I was recently watching Back to the Future on blu-ray at a friend's house with a few other people, and their TV had the motion smoothing turned on. It was driving me crazy, and I brought it up, and they all looked at me like I was Gengis Khan. I'm a big enough asshole that I paused the movie and fiddled around with their TV settings to turn it off, and was relieved to see it playing back at beautiful 24 fps... But everybody else was like, "Wait... did you change the thing? What's different?" We had in the room an age range from 18 to about 50, so all people who had grown up watching things the same way I did, and nobody but me gave a shit, or even noticed.

My point being that it MAY be a generational thing, but I think it will be between people like the people in this community, not the general population. Obviously six folks in a living room in Maine isn't a large enough sample size to make scientific claims, but we still like anecdotal evidence, right?

177

(19 replies, posted in Episodes)

I haven't seen Hunger Games or John Carter, but I still enjoyed this one. I always like hearing you guys discuss story structure, and as far as JC... I'm just fascinated by the failure of that thing. I didn't want it to bomb or anything, it wasn't something that was even on my radar until recently... But just the sheer number of bad decisions centered around a $250 million dollar "tentpole." It's amazing. I probably would have gone to see it if the lead had been pretty much anybody else. Except Sam Worthington.

I also heartily approve of the Brothers Bloom recommendation. That's a really fun movie, and Mark Ruffalo, Rachel Weisz, and Adrian Brody make a charming trio.

178

(569 replies, posted in Creations)

1.) I guess generally I'm sort of fast and at a medium volume. But I sometimes lapse into a mumble.

2.) Also that sort of flat, regionless American thing.

3.) Doesn't really make a difference to me. If I had to pick something I'd say I'm probably best at irritated or cluelessly happy.

4.) Nothing comes to mind.

5.) I'm pretty fluent.

6.) First thing that popped into my head was In Bruges, so I'll go with that, I guess.

179

(569 replies, posted in Creations)

I'm in. I'd be down for a big part if you need somebody to talk a lot or a small part if you need somebody to roll their eyes and huff or something. Basically whatever you need to fill in the blanks. I have a car, a camera, and a lot of free time...

180

(22 replies, posted in Off Topic)

Dark Coyote wrote:

I don't like to let go. George raped our childhoods and I want him to pay for it. I know that he never will but doesn't mean I can't want it.

I'm so tired of this overused, absurd phrase. I despise the special editions, there's not a single addition that I think helps the films, unless we want to count the digital recompositing work they did on the original elements. But Lucas didn't rape my childhood. Lucas pretty much gave me my childhood. The original Star Wars trilogy was a big part of my life, and a huge inspiration to me.

So he changed the movies, and in my opinion made them worse. And he refuses to release the original versions on blu-ray. The only way I can watch the versions I grew up with is those cruddy 4:3 letterbox DVD bonus feature versions. But that's not raping my childhood. That's pissing me off as an adult. Lucas' behavior today doesn't ripple back in time and affect what the original films did for my childhood. Nothing can take that away. Maybe he's robbing me from reliving that today, but nostalgia is overrated anyhow.

And the best part is... Lucas didn't put the versions I wanted out on blu-ray, so y'know what? I didn't buy them. Because nobody made me. I never have to see Greedo shoot first unless I want to, for some reason.

181

(209 replies, posted in Creations)

That was really enjoyable. I 1080'd it up and watched it on my HDTV, it was great. I have a pretty strict, "Shut it off if it's even the faintest bit shitty," policy for lengthy Youtube videos, so the fact that I sat through and enjoyed the whole thing says more about it than I'd be able to.

I would like to compliment the lighting, though. It seems simple, but at the same time it wouldn't be hard to believe that it was something you agonized over getting just right.

182

(48 replies, posted in Off Topic)

I feel better after reading this thread. Haven't been won over by these trailers either. I'm REALLY not digging the cinematography on display in the Avengers material we've seen so far. If it's not an action scene (or a low-angle shot, apparently...), they seem to be taking a, "Yeah, whatever, point the camera in the general direction of whoever's talking," kind of stance. With flat lighting, to boot. Joss Whedon devoted a whole featurette on the Serenity DVD to loving on Jack Green and his extended family... why the hell wasn't he contacted for this?

On top of that, of the Avengers ground-work movies I've seen... Iron Man's... And Iron Man 2 told me that talented people could make a bad movie with RDJ's Tony Stark in it, plus the Avengers tie-ins annoyed me. I know I'm can't be the only one getting a Transformers vibe from this trailer, and I'm so bored with superheroes at this point.

As for Joss Whedon, I pretty much take Teague's stance. I think he's a clever guy, and I always like hearing what he has to say, but I don't think I could call myself a Whedon fan. I like Firefly/Serenity and Dr. Horrible (and Toy Story, if that counts). I was sort of excited when they announced that the project was in his hands, if only for the prospect of hearing Robert Downey Jr. do Whedon dialogue. And yet after the trailers I find myself more interested in Cabin in the Woods than Avengers.

All that said... Scarlett Johansson looked seriously gorgeous in this trailer. I want to spend an afternoon with her in a small-town general store and buy her a butter churn or something.

183

(69 replies, posted in Episodes)

Jeffery, that was an interesting read. I must say, I disagree with you entirely, but it was interesting nevertheless. Your proposed Batman film doesn't sound too far removed from what... Was it the Wachowskis who were working on a Year One thing? I know Aronofsky was involved at some point, and wanted him to be like a guy in plastic sporting armor who was called Batman because he hit people with a bat or something.

And I would watch that movie. I would watch your movie too... If it weren't a Batman movie. It'd be an interesting, unique entry into the superhero film genre, but it would not be a Batman movie.

Also, I don't think it took balls for Nolan and co to keep The Dark Knight light on Batman. There were four previous movies that did the very same thing.

EDIT - Funny thing, one of my closest friends is named Jeffery, and he's the only person I know who spells it e-r-y, so I'm constantly having to remind myself that it's usually spelled Jeffrey when I write it out. Screwed myself over this time...

184

(69 replies, posted in Episodes)

For a while after it came out, I was totally in love with The Dark Knight. I had followed the production intensely, got involved in he viral marketing (and still have the free shit to prove it) and I was just totally amped for it. I saw it at a midnight showing, and again a week later, and I was just crazy about it. But four years later... It's still a very good movie, I think. But personally, I've cooled on superheroes. So there's a loss of luster there. It's far from the masterpiece I initially thought, and I've just lost most of my enthusiasm for it.

But also, upon rewatch, it doesn't hold up so well in comparison to its predecessor. I find myself much preferring Batman Begins. Begins is a very good movie that goes off the rails a bit in the third act. All of The Dark Knight is better than act three of Begins, but nothing in it hits the same highs as the first two-thirds of Begins. I have much the same feelings about the Iron Man movies, actually. Though specifically with Dark Knight, the Joker is better than the movie he's in. I think Heath Ledger deserved every bit of praise he got, and not just because they carted his naked ass out of a hotel room shortly before the release. He created a really interesting character that was straight out of the comics while also startlingly different from the Nicholson and Hamill portrayals.

One of the biggest downsides of The Dark Knight for me, though, are the visuals. If you just look at the film... It's Heat with DeNiro and Pacino in silly costumes. Gotham City is just Chicago, and that's lame. It's a flat, boring-looking movie with an obnoxious blue tint. Which is especially egregious because Begins is so beautiful. It's got atmosphere, there's a very film noir vibe to the photography in that film, and it makes Gotham feel so much more alive to me. Dark Knight needed the Narrows so hard.

And if I'm nit-picking more, Danny Elfman is a much better Batman composer than Hans Zimmer, who I've never cared for, and TDK underutilized the treasure that is Cillian Murphy.

As far as Batman's voice, I didn't have any problem understanding him in Dark Knight. That said, I prefer the Begins voice. Can't understand a damn word that's come out of Bane's mouth so far, though...

185

(198 replies, posted in Episodes)

I'm halfway through season three of Breaking Bad on Netflix. I like it, it's a good show, well above average... But coming off all the hype I find myself underwhelmed. My primary complaint is that it seems to rely an awful lot on coincidences to drive their plots. There are just plenty of shows on TV I'd rather watch than Breaking Bad.

Also, fxguide totally ruined a season four character death for me, so I feel a little bit of anger every time they're on screen, which is not the show's fault at all.

186

(25 replies, posted in Episodes)

So I let my Western boner control me, and I posted before I'd listened to the second half of the commentary. Where you guys both mentioned Assassination of Jesse James and asked about a self-aware Western, the equivalent of Galaxy Quest or Shaun of the Dead, after realizing you couldn't think of one off the top of your heads.

To which I offer up a tentative, Shanghai Noon? I haven't seen it in about a decade, so I'm a little fuzzy on the details. But as I recall, it treats its story fairly straight-faced while simultaneously poking fun at the genre tropes, usually with the Owen Wilson character. It's not on the same level of quality as Galaxy Quest and Shaun of the Dead, but I think it's trying to do the same kind of thing. I remember it being reasonably amusing, if totally disposable. But again... ten years. This is an attempt to answer the question, not a recommendation.

187

(25 replies, posted in Episodes)

There's another one I'd like to mention, The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford. It seems a fairly divisive movie, weirdly enough. People either love it or hate it. I fell under the love side of things. Great cast, engaging story, beautiful cinematography. It is long and slowly paced, which seems one of the most common criticisms, but I don't think it's a detriment in this case. In my mind it's one of the best films of the last decade.

That may just be because I'm really captivated by Casey Affleck, for some reason. I don't know what it is, but I love that guy.

188

(25 replies, posted in Episodes)

I'll go ahead and recommend The Man With No Name trilogy, or the Dollars trilogy, or whatever one cares to call it. Referring to A Fistful of Dollars, For a Few Dollars More, and The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly. Not REALLY a trilogy in the strictest sense, for those who didn't know. Those were, personally, the movies that showed me I could actually enjoy Westerns, a genre which I had had no interest in up until then. I love Sergio Leone's visual style so much, and the way he's able to build tension in a scene is amazing.

The thing I like about those in relation to Unforgiven is that Eastwood is pretty much playing the same character as he was in those three films. Munny is very much the natural progression of... I'll go with Blondie, because that's my favorite of Eastwood's no names.

I'll also second the recommendation of High Noon and Two Mules For Sister Sara, because why not?

189

(449 replies, posted in Off Topic)

Does nobody in marketing realize that they've totally devalued the term visionary? Absolutely everybody's a visionary director these days, it seems.

Personally, I don't think you count as a visionary unless your film contains gritty realism...  hmm

190

(32 replies, posted in Episodes)

This was hands down my favorite episode of the Intermission. I love hearing honest behind the scenes stories like this, as opposed to the documentaries and commentaries you get on new releases where everybody was great friends and every aspect of the film is amazing. I haven't seen Ark since it was released, but I'll have to check it out again after hearing all this. I don't remember ever noticing any green screen shots beyond the obvious, "that couldn't have been done any other way," kind of stuff.

Definitely hope you guys do more episodes like this. Any chance Dorkman could do one about The Descendants? I read the stuff he posted on his blog, but I think it'd be fascinating to hear more detail there. Although as I recall he maybe had to remove a post about it from his blog or something? So maybe that isn't possible.

191

(2,061 replies, posted in Episodes)

A Superman Returns commentary could be interesting. It wasn't an amazing movie, but big-screen Superman has never done much for me. I think Returns was the best attempt thus far, never understood the bizarre amount of hatred people on the internet seem to have for it. And as far as I'm concerned, Brandon Routh was a PERFECT Superman. I'm still disappointed that they didn't bring him back for Snyder's Man of Steel. The guy deserves a bitchin' speed-ramped, super-powered fight scene. And no, Scott Pilgrim doesn't count.

192

(1,649 replies, posted in Off Topic)

I found this really hypnotic:

193

(31 replies, posted in Episodes)

This was a fun listen. I also had a big commentary phase back when I first got into DVD. It went away after a couple years, but it's actually starting to come back.

Thought I'd chime in with my favorite commentary, which is for Kiss Kiss Bang Bang. It's Robert Downey Jr., Val Kilmer, and Shane Black, and it's hysterical. I had no idea Val Kilmer was so effortlessly funny. On top of that, you also get Shane Black being honest and at times even critical of certain aspects of the film. I tend to follow any viewing of Kiss Kiss Bang Bang immediately with the commentary.

194

(12 replies, posted in Episodes)

For anybody who's interested in that sort of thing, fxguide did a really interesting article on the Captain America Skinny Steve stuff they talk about here at length. There are a few cool before and after images, and a pretty in depth description of the process. http://www.fxguide.com/featured/case-st … rica-wimp/

Really enjoyed this episode. Love bake-off stories.

195

(47 replies, posted in Episodes)

Is it okay to bump a thread this old? I can't find mention of it in your rules anywhere...

I finally listened to this episode today. I'd been looking forward to it since it was released, but some movies I just want to sync up to the commentaries, and this was one of them. So I was waiting until I had The Shining on blu-ray. Anyhow, great episode you guys. Easily in my top ten.

I have my own little story about my first time seeing The Shining; When I was about five, my dad was watching in on VHS in the living room, and I wandered in, just in time to see the naked old hag sinking back down into the tub. I was absolutely horrified, and ran out of the house, and wouldn't go back inside for hours. It was an image that would pop back into my mind on occasion, and I had no idea what it was. My dad was always watching Columbo, so my child logic told me that must've been an episode of Columbo. Anyway, years later, when I was a teenager, I was watching The Shining for the first time, very late at night, and when the bathroom scene started I began feeling this really strong sense of dread, it was almost like a physical sensation in my chest. It wasn't until the nasty old bitch showed up that I realized what was going on. And that's my Shining story. Not as good as Trey's, but then I'm not as good as Trey.

The main reason I felt compelled to bump, though, is my one major disappointment with the episode. I got excited when you started mocking crazy Kubrick conspiracy theories, but then I was sad that you didn't touch on my favorite...

http://www.bibliotecapleyades.net/luna/ … ions10.htm

This guy is either legitimately insane or he's brilliantly taking the piss. Based on the rest of his website, I'd say the former, but I dunno. Maybe he's doing a Stephen Colbert.

196

(35 replies, posted in Creations)

Man, I've been a fan of your stuff for a while, but this is easily my favorite. Very unique, and I have absolutely no idea where it's going. And it could seemingly go ANYWHERE, which makes it exciting. I hope you do more episodes.

Also... love the fedora robot.

197

(11 replies, posted in Off Topic)

Trey wrote:

He said exactly the same thing after Return of the Jedi.    But I'd like to see him really do it this time, if he can.  American Graffiti was a nice little personal film, maybe he would have done those for his entire career if he hadn't gotten trapped in blockbuster hell.  B ut now that he's a billionaire who runs a media empire, I wonder if he can make a "personal" movie that normal people can relate to.   

But best of luck to him, says I.

He also said exactly the same thing after Revenge of the Sith. And he's spent the past seven years making The Clone Wars and Red Tails...

I'd also love to see him actually make good and do it, though. American Grafitti was really fun and I love THX 1138. Of course if he did make a movie I enjoyed it'd just be a set-up for the burning hatred and disillusionment I'd feel in thirty years when I can't get the original theatrical release on 4K Mega-Disc.

I'm interested in seeing a bunch, but there are only five I'm guaranteed to see in theaters. So... good cap, guy.

1.) Seven Psychopaths
2.) Skyfall
3.) Prometheus
4.) The Dark Knight Rises
5.) The Hobbit

199

(173 replies, posted in Episodes)

1.) Unforgiven
2.) Close Encounters of the Third Kind
3.) Batman Returns (I was sold just on Trey-talk... but WALKEN STORY!?!? Fuhgetabouddit)
4.) Citizen Kane
5.) The Dark Knight
6.) The Wizard of Oz

200

(21 replies, posted in Off Topic)

I just saw this yesterday, and I really enjoyed it. Well, enjoy probably isn't the right word, but it was a good movie, anyway. I'd seen the Swedish one, so I sort of knew what to expect out of it going in, but this version is a little neater overall, and had enough going for it that I was still totally engaged. So hoping Fincher does the other two books and makes better films of them than the Swedish fella did.

The real reason I'm posting, though, is that I actually thought of Down in Front in the theater when Mikael Blomkvist had a literal, "save the cat" moment. So I guess the friends in my head have put up a residence...