I wish I’d seen the oppression of the underclass in Gotham more explicitly, seen it rather than heard it spoken of, seen that the League has a point, and felt Batman’s helpless horror as the seething anger of the oppressed — and, perhaps, even of the righteous — became another weapon to fall into the wrong hands. As it is, it just passes in a “things are bad” montage and we have to move on to the next stage of the plot.
A friend of mine sent me this....
Which sparked a similar conversation. How would you portray such a world that is beyond saving, so much so that, Superman's last resort would be to go back in time and change how the city shapes up.
How would you show that cinematically? I, personally, think its very hard to do that. And that is one of the failings of the trilogy, as Dorkman wrote. It doesn't show us how Gotham is beyond saving or how in Batman's eye its almost beyond saving, but there's still hope.
We have to take the word of the movie on this and roll with it. But when the 1st and 3rd movie's entire backbone is that idea, the story strangely feels hollow from inside. Even though on the surface its racing through some really kool stuff.