redxavier wrote:Final Fantasy Spirits Within is a fascinating movie, if only because it's a Western-targeted film made by Japanese with all their sensibilities but intermixed with American movie cliches, so it comes with both an environmental message and a kick-ass band of marines cut from the Aliens cloth.
I heartily disagree. Spirits Within is a trainwreck.
See, when you slap the Final Fantasy sticker on a movie, you're making fans all over the world grow expectations. Spirits Within didn't deliver. At all.
It's a very well made movie, for its time, but it wasn't, and still isn't Final Fantasy. Did I want a J-pop-esque film with overly beautiful, yet emo characters that save the world while coping with their own problems?
...Kinda. But then Spirits Within came out, FF hadn't been stamped with the whole emo-thing. The latest game out, at the time, was FFIX, which was the prettiest game thus far, character-wise. And that game had Quina.
The games really defining the series at the time were 6 and 7. 6 didn't have the graphics to really make the beauty stamp, and had a compelling story, a great roster of characters, a friggin' 16-bit opera scene, and Kefka.
7, on the other hand, had existensial crisis, world peril, a rich world and Sephiroth.
These games really defined what Final Fantasy should be, and the film completely ruined it. It was set on earth, had only human characters, and a terrible roster. Aki Ross wasn't really interesting, Dr Cid wasn't either, and the badguy, whose name I can't even remember? Nah, gtfo dude.
Now Final Fantasy 7: Advent Children, on the other hand...
..Was even worse. Goddamn it.