On the show it was suggested that perhaps Godfather owes its reputation more to context than to what it is. But it's about the only film in my experience that is referenced across every generational and cultural subset I can think of. Even more than Star Wars. My grandfather, who never watched or talked about movies, would drop GF quotes. At-risk kids I tutored quoted GF. I quote GF. It's not just because it sold a bunch of tickets and did something new. Like Star Wars, I think it's because it touches on very universal ideas about family, loyalty, vengeance, and power.
First, on a technical level, it's really hard to think of a movie that gets as many facets of filmmaking so nearly perfect all at once. It doesn't matter what your bag is here. From acting, lighting, set-dec, music, editing, sound... each department had a lot to say about each scene. This is because they had a layered story to start with.
...you know what? This was about to become a tldr essay. Just go watch it again. I didn't like it the first time either. I think because of its reputation. "Oh. Really? This is the greatest film of all time?" It became one of my favorite movies after the second go.