Silent Hill (2006)

An interesting one really, I have mixed feelings on it. I'm a fan of the games and I think that this is one of the better video game adaptations out there.
As a fan, the main issue that gets brought up is the lead character Harry Mason was turned into Rose Da Silva. The director essentially wanted an all female cast and felt that Harry Mason (upon playing the game) had traits that would traditionally be associated with a mother, aka being compassionate and comforting to other characters, and going through hell to save their daughter. Ignoring all the unfortunate implications that this change now implies, the studio didn't like such a female dominance in the film and demanded a male character be thrown in.
This gives us Sean Bean as the husband to the main character. His scenes in the film are interesting in their own right. He's going after Rose to try and bring her and their daughter back safely and he's will to do anything to accomplish that. However his scenes feel tacked on (as they were) and actively pulls you out of the tense atmosphere that Rose's scenes provide. Sean Bean is quite good in this film and it honestly makes me wonder, why bother with making Harry into Rose if you've got him in it? I feel like he could of made a great lead.
Enough on that subject, lets talk about something else. The set and costume design. Give these people a medal, good lord. The atmosphere that the sets provide is very much like the games. Special props to the "double dare you" bathroom scene and the nurse scene. The sets are gorgeous to look at and not to mention the variation to the sets. Take for instance, the setting of the school. They had to keep track of four variants of it, the foggy abandoned variation, the hellish otherworld variation, 1970s still being used version and modern day abandoned version.
The monster design is also really impressive. All of the monsters bar CG bugs are skilled performers in costume and make up. They give unsettling, disturbing performances that are almost ruined by having additional CG applied and making them look fake. Special mention to that are the "grey children".
Its obvious that a lot of love was put into the film, occasionally doing shot for shot moments from the game. However theres occasional moments of plot weirdness, lines and the odd hammy over the top acting at times that drags the movie down.
I'd definitely suggest at least checking it out. Hell, it could even make for an interesting podcast. In the end, I suppose it's YMMV. I looked past its flaws to see all the workmanship that was put into it with its sets, props and make up work but others might not be so forgiving.
I heard that the sequel was pretty bad but it had a different director and writing team on that one. I haven't seen it so I can't really say.