Honestly, reading through the thread, I'm pretty sure what was expected and hoped for was a lighthearted thing where it's inherently assumed everyone respects each other and we just fuck around and talk about our varying opinions on a TV show.
I'm not sure how it got off the rails, but I'm willing to call it a fluke in this case. If it becomes a recurring thing, maybe we'll have to figure out how to address the miscommunication of tone and stuff like that, but... like I said, in the meantime, for this one, I'm thinkin' we call it a fluke and abandon the contention.