Topic: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

Just curious. Let's say Warner Brothers got Rowling to agree to a ninth film about Harry Potter, post-Hogwarts. They get HP editor Mark Day to rookie direct and get the principle cast but few supporters. Rowling gives frozen-smile support to the screenplay, which has something to do with zombies in Romania. Budget is 80% of Deathly Hallows 2.

You've been busy with work and travel, so you come upon a pay showing before hearing any reviews. It's called Harry Potter and the Caves of Androzani or some such.

Are you in or out?

The real question here, I suppose, is: could Potter have a life beyond the novels?

Warning: I'm probably rewriting this post as you read it.

Zarban's House of Commentaries

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

Not even out of morbid curiosity.

I grew up with the books and movies; the two might as well be the same thing to me. I love them both, albeit for different reasons. But ultimately, as much as I do love the movies, they are entities that cannot and will not exist without the books beside them.

So, to answer your question, Potter can't have a life beyond the novels. Potter is the novels. The movies aren't their own thing. Or, to boil it down even more, Potter is Rowling. A film that isn't based on her material isn't worth making.

And even if Rowling wrote the screenplay herself, recasting most of the supporting cast would make a distracting film with a totally different feel. Could you imagine a different actor as Snape? Or Neville? (Well, maybe you could, but I couldn't). I feel like it would change the tone of the film somehow; it would make it feel cheaper, like a low-rent sequel made years later as a cash-grab. Even if the budget was almost as large as Deathly Hallows 2.

So, no. I would not see that movie.

"The Doctor is Submarining through our brains." --Teague

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

Even with the books I haven't seen a single Potter movie.  So this question probably wasn't designed for me.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

no, absolutely not

Protection and power are overrated. I think you are very wise to choose happiness and love. -Uncle Iroh

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

Hell to the no.

Harry isn't like James Bond or Indiana Jones. He wasn't created to have thrilling but essentially unrelated adventures for as long as the author can come up with something. The Potter novels are one story about Harry's lifelong (at least until the age of 17) epic struggle with the incarnation of Ultimate Evil. It's not wizard of the week episodic stuff. You could do more stories with him like that, but the real story's been told, and anything else would feel feeble and desperate.

It's like we say on the show, a movie should ideally be about the most interesting thing that ever happened to those characters. I loved LOTR, but I'm not interested in a new movie about Sam's tenure as mayor of Hobbiton in the years that followed. There is no amount of thwarted turnip thieving that makes that as worth telling as the time he helped save the world from Sauron.

EDIT: it's also why I've never wanted to see a fourth BACK TO THE FUTURE. In the end, the trilogy is a single story (which, if we're honest, goes to the frontier-town mansion in the third act). The story was all wrapped up in the end. Another film would feel like the odd man out.

Last edited by Dorkman (2011-11-09 02:37:48)

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

Round 2
JK Rowling has confirmed having provided the story and worked closely with Steve Kloves on a ninth film about Harry Potter, post-Hogwarts, to be followed by a novelization. Alfonso Cuarón will direct, and the whole cast is on board, with a couple of minor exceptions. The story is one Rowling says occurred to her as a "natural extension" of the series before starting Deathly Hallows and involves Harry's tracking down the remaining minions of V across Europe which leads him back to uncover an astonishing secret at Hogwart's, and reputedly ends with him taking a position at the school. Budget is equal to that of Deathly Hallows 2.

You've been busy and the details have been kept quiet, but initial reviews are good. It's called Harry Potter and the Keys of Marinus or some such.

Are you in or out?

Warning: I'm probably rewriting this post as you read it.

Zarban's House of Commentaries

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

Wait, is this an actual thing or are you just spitballing here?

Eddie Doty

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

I think the problem here is, it's too soon. People have been awash in Potter books and movies for a decade or two. Give people, even hard core fans, an excuse to say "no more!" and I think they'd have a good chance of doing it. Now, ask the question in five years, when people have had time to suffer Potter withdrawal, or think to themselves, "I wonder what other stories could be told...", and maybe there will be a market.

I write stories! With words!
http://www.asstr.org/~Invid_Fan/

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

Zarban is powerful, but I'm not sure he's that powerful.

Extended Edition - 146 - The Rise Of Skywalker
VFX Reel | Twitter | IMDB | Blog

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

Eddie wrote:

Wait, is this an actual thing or are you just spitballing here?

This is just spitballing. I'll take that as an "interested".  big_smile

Invid wrote:

I think the problem here is, it's too soon.

I don't think you can wait much. It'll take two to three years to get it on screen as it is. The adult cast will start retiring / "retiring" with great rapidity, and the young cast won't stay cute forever.

Warning: I'm probably rewriting this post as you read it.

Zarban's House of Commentaries

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

Round 2 I would pay to see in 3D, and pimp it to all my friends*.

(*) on the internet**.
(**) http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-lDBOENn3iTo/ThiB9hvASPI/AAAAAAAAA9E/exZzhE_JV4Q/s1600/4_Forever_Alone_meme_even_more-s500x439-97058-580.jpg

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

Zarban wrote:
Invid wrote:

I think the problem here is, it's too soon.

I don't think you can wait much. It'll take two to three years to get it on screen as it is. The adult cast will start retiring / "retiring" with great rapidity, and the young cast won't stay cute forever.

Which is why any sequels would probably be about their kids. It is, after all, a story about a school. You need school age characters. So, time isn't a factor as everyone can be replaced.

I write stories! With words!
http://www.asstr.org/~Invid_Fan/

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

Okay. Round 2 is much better (Rowling's heavy involvement helps), but I agree with Dorkman. It would feel like the odd man out. I'd rather that Rowling wrote the book version first if she honestly thought that it was a natural extension of the story.

That said, if she decides to do little short stories set in the universe, I'd love the 30 page adventure of Harry tracking down the last Death Eaters.

"The Doctor is Submarining through our brains." --Teague

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

Yes, absolutely, to either option.

Frankly, I've always considered the movies a pale imitation of the books.  So pale, in fact, that they are usually less than enjoyable experiences, because as I'm watching them I'm seeing somewhat the same story I'm familiar with but with none of the magic of the books.

Now, if I'd seen the films without reading the books, I'd probably think they were okay.  Likewise, I'd be WAY more excited for a brand new Potter story independent of a book than I was for the movies (of which I haven't seen the last two).  Without needing to be shackled to a very long book, they could build a Potter story made SPECIFICALLY to be a film, and tell a good FILM story.  And since it wouldn't be a story told masterfully in a book and then adapted as best they could into a movie, it would be fresh, and we'd all be hearing the story for the first time.

Honestly, I'd be tremendously excited and would bet money the product would be better than the "book" films.

When.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

Round 3
JK Rowling has confirmed having written another Harry Potter novel, this one describing the death eaters' triggering of a dark threat from within Hogwarts. It reportedly includes a shocking character turn and ends with Harry's rise to youngest headmaster and the birth of his first child. It's a story that Rowling says she's been planning secretly for quite a while and for which she quietly laid in hooks and hints that she made sure were included in the the last three movies.

Rowling has worked with Kloves on the screen adaptation, so the book will be published just weeks before the film debuts. David Yates will direct again, and the whole cast is on board. Budget is 110% of Deathly Hallows 2. Initial reviews are good, and promise that the film will raise eyebrows. It's called Harry Potter and the Curse of Peladon or some such.

Are you in or out?

Warning: I'm probably rewriting this post as you read it.

Zarban's House of Commentaries

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

Your apparent pleasure in making everyone crave the impossible is perverse.

So in it should be illegal.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

So in it should be illegal.

Teague Chrystie

I have a tendency to fix your typos.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

I'll take that as an "interested". tongue

I strongly think that there will be more Harry Potter material, especially a movie. There's just so much of the wizarding world outside of Hogwarts to explore and SO MUCH MONEY on the table. Seriously, could YOU resist $1 BILLION for the sake of maintaining the artistic integrity of a some children's novels?

I do think the result would fall somewhere between round 1 and round 2. No way Rowling has been planning a secret epilog, but I don't think it would be half-assed either.

Think of the trailer: Hedwig flying ... leaves swirling ... the familiar music, but with a darker tone ... Ginny looking worried ... a scream ... McGonagall: "Something evil has come to Hogwarts" ... flashes of death eaters ... martial music ... Hermione trapped and screaming "Ron!" ... Ron peering boldly in a doorway with his wand lit. ... A first year with a Defence Against the Dark Arts book, addressing an adult: "Professor Potter?" ... Fade to black ... fade up on Harry to Hermione: "Our work isn't finished." ... a slamming door.

Warning: I'm probably rewriting this post as you read it.

Zarban's House of Commentaries

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

STOP IT!

*fap* *fap* *fap*

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

Oh hell to the yes.

"The Doctor is Submarining through our brains." --Teague

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

I don't really care about a 9th Potter film (I've yet to see the 5th, the 6th and both of the 7th's) but when Dorkman mentioned a 4th BTTF I remembered just how scared I get sometimes.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

Sure, but Marty McFly didn't attend Time High and buy his hoverboard in Futuristic Alley and keep his golden hours and silver minutes in Zemeckis Bank and play timeball and get bothered by a time elf and nearly get his soul sucked out by time dementors and sneak into the Ministry of Time....

Potter's world is just a whole lot richer, and very little of it has been explored.

Oh, and thanks a lot....
http://www.zarban.com/no-bttf.jpg

Warning: I'm probably rewriting this post as you read it.

Zarban's House of Commentaries

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

Woah, I didn't suggest BTTF as a movie for them to do a commentary for, so it doesn't sount. And my point is- I love BTTF, I don't really care about Potter. A 9th movie would mean nothing to me smile

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

For anyone interested, I wrote a detailed outline/brief treatment that I think would work for a ninth Harry Potter movie.

Harry Potter and the Temblor Bell (PDF)

Note: I've broken it down the same way I broke down all the Potter movies for study (5 minute chunks); if my estimates are accurate, it clocks in at 145 minutes.

Warning: I'm probably rewriting this post as you read it.

Zarban's House of Commentaries

Re: Would you see a 9th Harry Potter movie?

Zarban wrote:

For anyone interested, I wrote a detailed outline/brief treatment that I think would work for a ninth Harry Potter movie.

Harry Potter and the Temblor Bell (PDF)

Note: I've broken it down the same way I broke down all the Potter movies for study (5 minute chunks); if my estimates are accurate, it clocks in at 145 minutes.

I...I...

Yes. I would absolutely watch that movie.

clap

"The Doctor is Submarining through our brains." --Teague

Thumbs up Thumbs down