Topic: About Star Wars. And a girlfriend.

My girlfriend has decided she's gonna watch Star Wars, to once and for all properly understand all the damn puns, references, parodies and whatnots, and to.. well, have seen the films.

Problem is, I don't know which versions to show her.

Now, before y'all go "THEATRICAL VERSION ZOMG!", let's look at the subject here. My girlfriend was hesitant to watch the Back the Future trilogy, based on the fact that "they're old!". She was also drawing her "old" film experience based on "King Kong" (The ancient one), and not being apt in the film world, I suppose she automatically assumed all "old" films looked as terrible(now, not then). She was pleasantly surprised by the trilogy, though, and didn't mind the old vfx as much as I feared.

But SW is another bag. The theatrical versions, although superior, are aged, at least when you look at the vfx. I'm worried they might take her out of the experience and make her laugh or writhe in pain, instead of being taken into the story.



Also, note that the Blu-Ray versions were never even considered. It's the Theatrical DVD's, or the 2004 DVD's.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: About Star Wars. And a girlfriend.

2004 DVDs, skip the Jabba scene in Star Wars.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: About Star Wars. And a girlfriend.

@marcusvowell  -  facebook.com/marcusvowell

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: About Star Wars. And a girlfriend.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: About Star Wars. And a girlfriend.

I'm not a Star Wars fan and I don't have a girlfriend, so I'll never have this problem.....

Oh, wait a minute.......<cries>

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: About Star Wars. And a girlfriend.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: About Star Wars. And a girlfriend.

Make it a test, show her the originals - if she doesn't laugh, she's a keeper.

Re: About Star Wars. And a girlfriend.

Welcome to the boards, Liam!

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: About Star Wars. And a girlfriend.

A newbie! Welcome, Liam smile

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: About Star Wars. And a girlfriend.

Teague: Noted, but with the influence of Marcus' post.

Squiggly: As far as I'm concerned, there really only are 3 SW films, but if she's interested, those other 3 are her choice, not mine.

Liam: welcome, but... I don't know about that. She was already a keeper over a year ago wink

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: About Star Wars. And a girlfriend.

Re: About Star Wars. And a girlfriend.

Yes, I got that, but I'm not going to the extreme levels of checking out Adywans edit, a revisited edit, or the phantom edits. It's the films as they are, or nothing.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: About Star Wars. And a girlfriend.

Figure the Adywan has the best aspects of everything, and is the newest, best looking version of that film I've seen.

But I'm really not too into Star Wars.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: About Star Wars. And a girlfriend.

Nor am I, it was her idea, but I'm not going to show her a damn fan-edit, no matter how much it improves the original.
It's like showing her Scary Movie, telling her it's Scream.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: About Star Wars. And a girlfriend.

If she prefers Episode I, then... "you need some space but you still want to be friends"

not long to go now...

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: About Star Wars. And a girlfriend.

It's not as much 'converting her to love SW' as it is 'hope she enjoys the films enough to sit thru them'. I really don't care about star wars anymore anyway.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: About Star Wars. And a girlfriend.

There's a lot to be said for the 'you had to be there' school of film criticism. That is, classic films seen for the first time decades afterwards quite often appear just 'okay' to a newbie. Citizen Kane is a fine respectable film,  but I doubt many young people love it the way they love films from their own generation.

If you were there for Star Wars or Jaws or The Godfather in the 1970s, they're going to mean more to you than seeing them on TV for the first time in 2012.

There's probably many exceptions, but I think statistically it's less likely (all else being equal) to fall in love with an old old movie than it is with a movie from your own time. Movies don't just age due to VFX or resolution, there's... average edit-times, how sentimental v cynical/edgy it is, how PG-13 or R-rated it is, etc.

not long to go now...

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: About Star Wars. And a girlfriend.

Re: About Star Wars. And a girlfriend.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: About Star Wars. And a girlfriend.

I'm way more excited than I should be about getting a shout out haha  clap

Re: About Star Wars. And a girlfriend.

not long to go now...

Thumbs up Thumbs down