The Last Airbender is the most uncomfortable, mind-boggling, overstuffed, overcrowded film adaptation I've seen since David Lynch's Dune.

And this chick's hairstyle... did Shyamalan really not notice this?

1) Battlefield Earth
2) Dark Knight
3) Unforgiven
4) Close Encounters
5) Batman Returns
6) The Happening

1)transformers 3
2)the wizard of oz
3)kick ass
4)the dark knight
5)cowboys and aliens
6)close encounters

If anyone's interested here are the standings as of right now.

(Yes, I actually fucking counted them...yes, I am exceedingly bored right now...and yes, I am also slightly drunk.)

The Dark Knight : 159
The Last Airbender : 76
Who Framed Roger Rabbit? : 76
Unforgiven : 71
Batman Return : 69
Transformers 3 : 67
Kick-Ass : 58
Super 8 : 52
Close Encounters of the Third Kind : 50
Citizen Kane : 48
Lethal Weapon :39
The Wizard of Oz : 38
Battlefield Earth : 38
Cowboys & Aliens : 27
The Happening : 25
My Favorite Martian : 20
American Beauty : 4

And for some reason these three...cause apparently someone can't read...:

Barry Lyndon : 3
The Road : 2
Requiem For A Dream : 1

As you can see, we have a pretty clear leader, though the rest is anyone's game.

You know you would have gotten a much more accurate count if you'd had people rank all eighteen films, or at least their top ten,

Aw, dammit. C'mon Lethal Weapon! Although, that's going to be my first commentary, so maybe not

5 of my six are currently at the top

1) Lethal Weapon
2) The Dark Knight
3) The Wizard of Oz 
4) Kick-Ass
5) Cowboys & Aliens
6) Who Framed Roger Rabbit?

Here´s my 6 cents:

1) Who Framed Roger Rabbit?
2) American Beauty
3) Lethal Weapon
4) Cowboys & Aliens
5) Batman Returns (Trey worked on it)
6) Citizen Kane

1. The Wizard of Oz
2. Unforgiven
3. My Favorite Martian
4. Batman Returns
5. Close Encounters of the Third Kind
6. Citizen Kane (but only in character as crew members)

Wow, 49 folks have voted. And what do you know, the top 6 have changed quite a bit since the weekend.
Dark Knight 162
Unforgiven 87
Who Framed Roger Rabbit? 81
Last Airbender 78
Batman Returns 77
Kickass 69

KickAss is on the list because it's a movie we still want to do.  If it ends up a winner, it won't be the first one we re-did after a failed first attempt.

Interesting, you seem to have 1027 points with that. By my calculation there should be 1022 points total from the 49 voters so far - 21 each minus 6 points since rtambree chose 3 movies not from the list and 1 point by Pfosback who listed Dark Knight twice. I took into consideration the changed votes.

These are my current numbers, the big difference is the Dark Knight's 10 points:
77    Batman Returns (Trey worked on it)
162    The Dark Knight
30    American Beauty
69    Kick-Ass
49    Lethal Weapon
78    The Last Airbender
87    Unforgiven
24    My Favorite Martian (Trey worked on it)
67    Transformers 3
31    Cowboys & Aliens
25    The Happening
81    Who Framed Roger Rabbit?
54    Close Encounters of the Third Kind
51    Citizen Kane
50    The Wizard of Oz
49    Super 8
38    Battlefield Earth

I separated out results by voter, but admit I could have put a vote on the wrong line.

Taking a look at Dark Knight, it was voted for 38 times.
12x 1st place
7x 2nd place
6x 3rd place
8x 4th place
2x 5th place
3x 6th place

I'll send over my spreadsheet at the end.