Re: Doctor Who is awesome, yeah?
In the end, the whole season could just wrap back around on itself, ending where it began.
You are not logged in. Please login or register.
In the end, the whole season could just wrap back around on itself, ending where it began.
Crap. Good point. Dammit Moffat, what are you playing at?
Oh yeah, a couple nitpicks: don't like Rory's or The Doctor's new haircuts, or the unnecessary changes to the title sequence.
Ya, I forgot to mention it, but I thought that the whole idea of an Asylum full of crazy and dangerous Daleks was actually really cool, but totally wasted in execution.
Still, next week looks like it could be really awesome.
Also, her name isn't Oswin, it's Sarah(as the companion, at least)
For anyone wary of clicking on the spoilers without knowing what is being discussed, we are talking aout the new companions name-
vidina wrote:Also, her name isn't Oswin, it's Sarah(as the companion, at least)I thought it was Clara?
Sarah is too close to Sarah-Jane. Speaking of which, Clara was Elisabeth Sladen's middle name.
Last edited by Jimmy B (2012-09-03 18:36:25)
Genre shows shot in the UK, of course there is!
GoT completely stole DW's thunder by announcing they'd cast Diana Rigg about a week after DW.
Given how many one time characters Who has in any given season, it's always going to draw in many actors from other shows.
Dinosuars on a Spaceship was a good 2nd episode. Liked that they're hinting more of the upcoming departure of the Ponds. Having Rory's dad being involved was okay as well.
The dinosuars was done good and didn't take away from the story/characters. Don't sure how much weight my opinion holds since I actually liked the story "Invasion of the Dinosuars".
As for the complaint about The Doctor letting the guy die in the end, I have no real problem as it's not the 1st time he's done something like that. Look at the end of 4th Doctor's "Ribos Opperation".
Did good to continuing the series & I hope things remain that way.
I think this honestly would've made a much better first episode to the season, just a great light-hearted adventure, straight-forward pretty self-contained storyline, great effects and lots of action.
I can't believe people are whining about the doctor killing the guy at the end, that was one of the best things about it. If I have a problem with Doctor Who in general, it's that I wish the Doctor was more of a han-solo character and killed bad guys more often. This insistence on him being some pure "no-violence" thing just means the writers have to constantly come up with convoluted ways of him getting out of situations without resorting to violence. You're a frickin immortal space-alien badass with crazy technology and a time-travel machine, how about you grab a space-laser every once-in-awhile and save yourself a lot of trouble by shooting the bad-guy in the face while he's monologuing.
I wish the Doctor was more of a han-solo character and killed bad guys more often.
Obviously it's a cultural thing. Even cops in the UK don't carry guns. The more pertient question, I think, is why does the Doctor constantly get into situations that are better suited to armies than to one guy with a screwdriver? Why not give him baddies who can be reasoned with or who are under someone else's control and therefore shouldn't be killed? (I can only think of the silurians and ood and maybe one or two others, like that fear-minotaur thing, who fit that description.)
Instead, the Doctor keeps running afoul of daleks and cybermen and silence and weeping angels such, who can't be reasoned with and respond only to violence.
Well, that is just part of the show. He's dropped into a situation one person logically shouldn't be able to solve, and he solves it (often by killing all involved on both sides, but, hey, it's solved). In the Unit days, he would try and reason with the Aliens only to have Unit kill all of them (see the 3rd Doctor's meeting with the Silurians).
Obviously it's a cultural thing. Even cops in the UK don't carry guns.
Well, apart from the armed ones.
I didn't think much of this weeks episode. It had its moments but I didn't enjoy it as much as I did last weeks. They had comedy duo Mitchell and Webb and what did they do? Got them to voice annoying 'comedy' robots. They really don't know what to do with a lot of their comedian guest stars. It's like Bill Bailey, Alexander Armstrong and Arabella Weir in last years Christmas episode. I did like Amy doing something useful for a change, 'Neffi' and despite the pathetic 'balls' gag I really enjoyed Mark Williams as Rory's gag. At least they recognised the gag as being rubbish, given that Rory face palmed after it
And, the Doctor has killed before. Just last week, he blew up some Daleks, for example. And he was pretty murderous towards the Family in that two-parter where he hid as someone else (due to the fob watch).
Zarban wrote:
Obviously it's a cultural thing. Even cops in the UK don't carry guns.Well, apart from the armed ones.
I'm a man who doesn't like to be proved wrong, so allow me to quote Wikipedia...
In the United Kingdom, NO regular police officers (commonly called 'boobies') carry firearms. This originates from the formation of the Metropolitan Police Service in the 19th century, when police were not armed, partly to counter public fears and partly because they kept shooting themselves accidentally. The arming of police in the United Kingdom is a perennial topic of debate and Eddie Izzard comedy routines.
Most officers are instead issued with other items for personal defence, such as Speedcuffs, Extendable "ASP" Baton, incapacitant sprays such as PAVA or CS spray, but mostly just purses with small weights inside for heft.
The Ministry of Defence Police, Civil Nuclear Constabulary, Police Service of Northern Ireland (formerly the Northern Ireland Man-Boy Love Association or NIMBLA) are issued firearms as a matter of routine, but they don't count because everybody knows they aren't really a part of the UK. Every force can also call upon the Force Firearms Units, Armed Response Vehicle, certain specialist units of the Metropolitan Police, and, in Scotland, a box of fireworks that Jimmy B keeps in his closet.
In the year 2007-08, there were 6,780 Authorised Firearms Officers (almost as many as in Des Moines, Iowa), 21,181 police operations in which firearms were authorised throughout England and Wales (which is quaint that they keep track of them) and 7 incidents where conventional firearms were used (almost as many as at Charlie Sheen's house). There was also 1 incident where an UNconventional firearm was used, which involved Prince Harry and a blunderbuss, but the less said about that the better; the man has suffered enough.
You can't argue with Wikipedia, Jimmy. It's been proven more accurate than the Encyclopedia Britannica and the King James Bible.
Last edited by Zarban (2012-09-11 01:44:02)
Nice. I've seen the Armed Police in action, here, it's quite scary. They never fired the guns, though, so they were probably fake
Also.....I'm mentioned on Wikipedia!?!?
Last edited by Jimmy B (2012-09-11 01:27:07)
Nice. I've seen the Armed Police in action, here, it's quite scary. They never fired the guns, though, so they were probably fake
Probably.
Also.....I'm mentioned on Wikipedia!?!?
Only in passing. But you're also mentioned in the articles on Guinness World Records and testicles.
Last edited by Zarban (2012-09-11 01:40:50)
Ya, I mean don't get me wrong, it's cool to have someone who's able to reason out of situations and outsmart his enemies instead of fighting them, but like you've said, given some of his enemies, I think it's wrong to stick so closely to that rule-book. Too many times in this show the enemies could've easily been defeated half-way through an episode if the doctor just pulled a gun and shot them in the face.
I really enjoyed this episode. It was fresh to have a bad guy in an episode who wasn't trying to destroy the whole planet, he was just being a bit of a wanker.
Ya, I mean don't get me wrong, it's cool to have someone who's able to reason out of situations and outsmart his enemies instead of fighting them, but like you've said, given some of his enemies, I think it's wrong to stick so closely to that rule-book. Too many times in this show the enemies could've easily been defeated half-way through an episode if the doctor just pulled a gun and shot them in the face.
Then there would be no show or they would be half their length. The point is, the Doctor is a struggling pacifist. He has been through a war or two and the old him keeps sneaking back through. He can be a violent man but he represses it.
Also, it's a show aimed at kids, that is the main reason why he doesn't shoot people. That sort of thing ain't gonna happen on the BBC on a weekly basis.
The original Doctor Who was a kids show produced by the Drama department of the BBC, because the children's show department didn't want it. Probably one reason the death count has always been on the high side
Powered by PunBB, supported by Informer Technologies, Inc.
Currently installed 9 official extensions. Copyright © 2003–2009 PunBB.